The Truth Behind Cover Songs on YouTube

Watch The Truth Behind Cover Songs on YouTube on YouTube

Watch the video on YouTube

Covers aren't just for weddings and pub gigs. Some covers outshine the original, think Hendrix's All Along the Watchtower or Jeff Buckley's Hallelujah, and they're one of the best ways to grow an audience on YouTube. My very first video was a cover, filmed standing on my parents' bed.

But there's a lot of confusion about copyright, so here's what I've learnt from years of posting them. I'm not a lawyer; this is based on my own experience.

A very short history

The US Copyright Act of 1909 introduced the compulsory mechanical licence: anyone could record a song once it had been released, as long as they followed the rules and paid. Soon after, a famous Supreme Court case established that songwriters should be paid for public performances, which led to the blanket licences that collecting societies use today.

How it works on YouTube now

Some advice says you need a lawyer, a mechanical licence and a sync licence. Technically correct, but unnecessary for most musicians. YouTube's Content ID handles it:

  • Upload a cover and the song is usually identified automatically, often before the video is public.
  • The rights holder then chooses to block it, mute it, take all the ad revenue, or share it with you if you're in the Partner Programme.
  • A Content ID claim is not the same as a copyright strike. Strikes are for re-uploading someone else's actual video, and they can get your channel removed.

Who allows covers?

There's no definitive list. Most publishers see covers as easy money and exposure. Remember Dreams going viral on TikTok almost 50 years after release. Some artists and catalogue owners block them. I've only ever had one video taken down, a Prince cover years ago. Some artists actively encourage covers: Yusuf / Cat Stevens invited covers for an album anniversary and even commented on mine.

A good test: search for other covers of the song. If plenty exist, you're probably fine. If there are suspiciously few, stay clear.

What covers actually earn

At the time of filming:

  • Sultans of Swing with Josh Turner: 3.8 million views and about £4,500, which looked like roughly a 50/50 split with the songwriter. It also brought in 26,000 subscribers and paid back the cost of travelling to New York to film it.
  • Shape of You: almost nothing. The label took all the ad revenue, so only YouTube Premium income came through.
  • Flowers (with my trio): a healthy share, including Premium income. I also used it to promote my Ableton production course.

Premium viewers do pay creators, even though they don't see ads. It's just reported separately.

The bottom line

Covers can grow your audience and sometimes earn money, but they're not your original work, and sometimes exposure is the only reward. They're a great gateway to writing your own songs, which is what my songwriting course is for.

Previous
Previous

Writing and Recording a Song in an Hour

Next
Next

Robert Johnson: The King of the Delta Blues