In this video I show how I took four simple chords and made them interesting enough to carry a whole song. The song is "Drop, Drop, Slow Tears" from my debut album, Super. Sexy. Heartbreak.
Where the idea came from
At university I overheard a choir singing "Drop, Drop, Slow Tears", a poem by Phineas Fletcher from the 1600s, set to music by Orlando Gibbons. I thought those words would be a brilliant start to an unhinged heartbreak song.
1. Add sevenths for instant colour
The basic progression is four plain chords: E minor, A minor, G and F#. The single change that transforms it is adding a seventh to each:
- Em becomes Em7
- Am becomes Am7
- G becomes G7
- F# becomes F#m7
The extra colour also gives the vocal melody more notes to explore, so it can be more interesting too.
2. Add rhythm
Static chords are flat, so I added Latin-inspired syncopation in the right hand. Suddenly the chords become a riff. It's simple fingerstyle, using just my thumb and first two fingers to create the syncopated pattern.
3. Lift the melody for the chorus
In the verse, the vocal and guitar sit in roughly the same range. A leading note takes us into the chorus, where the melody jumps well above. That change in register tells the listener they're in chorus territory. I also put emphasis on the important words: a swoop on "love", and the highest note on the word that matters most after it, "blind". The song isn't about being in love; it's about blaming yourself.
4. Use repetition, with a twist
Repetition makes a chorus catchy, because people hear the words and can sing along quickly. But I wanted the chorus to have a split personality: the lead vocal varies its phrasing, while panned backing vocals repeat the same phrase an octave above.
5. Add space
After all that drama I had to get back into the second verse, still with only four chords. So I added space: the band stops, I skip the first chord entirely, and the gap creates tension. The melody also gets more varied and raw as the anger builds.
6. Add a surprise
Then comes a surprise chord the listener hasn't heard before. It's the same trick Fleetwood Mac use in "Dreams", where you think there are only two chords until an unexpected one appears. (More on that in why "Dreams" is perfect.)
7. Change the groove
To keep the energy up at the end, rather than just repeating the chorus, the studio recording throws in a total groove change and a gritty slide solo from Ariel Posen. Not everyone has Ariel on speed dial, but a change of feel works with any instrument.
The takeaway
Dynamics, upgraded chords, space, surprise and a groove change: contrast, even when you're using the same four chords all the way through. The chords don't have to be complicated; they just need to be colourful. Listen to the full band recording and see what you'd do differently.
My songwriting course goes much deeper into techniques like these, and my Fingerstyle Guitar course teaches the right-hand patterns.
