I'm Leaving Spotify

Watch I'm Leaving Spotify on YouTube

Watch the video on YouTube

It started with an email from Spotify about another price rise, with still no mention of paying artists more fairly. I've used Spotify for over a decade and discovered so many artists through it. But I'd started to wonder if it had made me too comfortable. I saved albums I never went back to, skipped songs I liked, and let music become background hum.

So I cancelled my subscription. Not in protest, just out of curiosity. I wanted to see what happens when I pay directly for the music I love.

What you told me

I wrote about it in my newsletter and got hundreds of long, thoughtful replies. The same themes came up again and again:

  1. Streaming has made us lazy without meaning to. Several of you said Spotify didn't kill vinyl, it killed the ritual of listening to a whole album.
  2. Ownership matters again. One reader worked out that buying the albums he really loves would cost less than a year's subscription, and he'd own them forever. Many of you are also paying for music twice through YouTube Premium or Amazon Prime without realising.
  3. Discovery isn't happening where Spotify says it is. Many of you found my music on YouTube, not through algorithm playlists.
  4. The iPod is having a renaissance. Old iPods, MP3 players and Discmans are back because limits feel like a luxury.
  5. Music had become background noise, and people are pushing back.
  6. The ethics bother people, from falling payouts to AI.
  7. Simpler listening makes people happier. Listen to less, but listen better.

Why it matters to me as an artist

Streaming has real benefits: it's convenient, and family plans are great for sharing music. I'm not telling anyone to leave. But if I'd relied on Spotify, I wouldn't have earned back even 5% of what my album cost to make. Super. Sexy. Heartbreak. exists because people bought physical copies.

Physical records also show the difference between real artists and AI-generated music. AI "artists" don't press vinyl, commission artwork or argue with a mastering engineer.

Music is an experience, not a feed. If you want to own mine, it's in my store.

Previous
Previous

My First Guitar Lesson with Marty Schwartz

Next
Next

How Much Money I Lost on Tour