It started with an email from Spotify about another price rise, with still no mention of paying artists more fairly. I've used Spotify for over a decade and discovered so many artists through it. But I'd started to wonder if it had made me too comfortable. I saved albums I never went back to, skipped songs I liked, and let music become background hum.
So I cancelled my subscription. Not in protest, just out of curiosity. I wanted to see what happens when I pay directly for the music I love.
What you told me
I wrote about it in my newsletter and got hundreds of long, thoughtful replies. The same themes came up again and again:
- Streaming has made us lazy without meaning to. Several of you said Spotify didn't kill vinyl, it killed the ritual of listening to a whole album.
- Ownership matters again. One reader worked out that buying the albums he really loves would cost less than a year's subscription, and he'd own them forever. Many of you are also paying for music twice through YouTube Premium or Amazon Prime without realising.
- Discovery isn't happening where Spotify says it is. Many of you found my music on YouTube, not through algorithm playlists.
- The iPod is having a renaissance. Old iPods, MP3 players and Discmans are back because limits feel like a luxury.
- Music had become background noise, and people are pushing back.
- The ethics bother people, from falling payouts to AI.
- Simpler listening makes people happier. Listen to less, but listen better.
Why it matters to me as an artist
Streaming has real benefits: it's convenient, and family plans are great for sharing music. I'm not telling anyone to leave. But if I'd relied on Spotify, I wouldn't have earned back even 5% of what my album cost to make. Super. Sexy. Heartbreak. exists because people bought physical copies.
Physical records also show the difference between real artists and AI-generated music. AI "artists" don't press vinyl, commission artwork or argue with a mastering engineer.
Music is an experience, not a feed. If you want to own mine, it's in my store.
