I've always loved sad songs. A good songwriter can conjure a moment of transcendent beauty and pain from just a few words and chords, and make you recognise yourself, feeling a kinship with them or their characters. We all suffer at some point, and we all try to avoid pain. So why do I take pleasure in sad songs, actively seek them out, and mostly write them too?
We play them more
A University of Michigan study found that people whose favourite songs were happy had listened to them about 175 times on average, compared with around 800 times for people who preferred sad songs. Those listeners described a deeper connection to the music: feelings of beauty, transcendence, nostalgia and common humanity.
What's happening in the brain
There's nothing straightforwardly sad about a minor key. When you listen to music, several brain regions linked to motivation, reward and emotion come into play. A lifetime of listening conditions you to recognise patterns, even without training, so you predict what's coming next. When you're right, you feel the pleasure of having your expectations confirmed, with a lovely dopamine hit from the anticipation.
Much of our response is cultural, too: we're taught that certain songs are sad or romantic. Psychologists distinguish between perceived emotion (what you think you should feel) and felt emotion (what you actually feel). Context and personal history matter enormously. If you played a song on repeat through a terrible breakup, you'll carry that baggage every time you hear it.
Why I write sad songs
I've had my share of painful breakups, and people often ask me, "Who hurt you?" when I play. But I'm a relatively happy person. For me, writing about failed relationships is cathartic, and when I perform those songs I feel detached from the person who felt the pain, because I've transformed it into something else. I've decided to embrace it without shame, which is why my debut album is called Super. Sexy. Heartbreak. Heartbreak is universal; you don't need to be going through a breakup to recognise yourself in it.
Suffering, empathy and redemption
Nick Cave, the most eloquent chronicler of pain and darkness, has written that understanding suffering as a universal, unifying force helps us see people more compassionately and forgive the world and ourselves. If we don't transform our suffering, he argues, we pass it on to others; its value is the chance it gives us to become better people.
We're social animals. Empathy, the ability to understand and share another's feelings, is essential for a pack. When we see someone crying, we feel the urge to check they're okay. By recognising that we all suffer, we can turn our own pain and longing into compassion.
Bittersweet
I recently read Susan Cain's Bittersweet: How Sorrow and Longing Make Us Whole. Her argument is that embracing life's bittersweet side leads to growth, and that understanding loss can teach us new ways of living and creating. She suggests what we're really craving is a state of longing: joy laced with sorrow, triggered by something so exquisite it seems to come from another world. That's why we give artists and musicians such status: they bring us a breath of that magic, if only for a moment. And longing, she says, is the source of our greatest ambitions and our loves.
Melancholy is not depression
It's important to distinguish the two. Melancholy goes back to ancient Greece, where Hippocrates described the melancholic as a thoughtful ponderer, creative but sensitive to the world's cruelty. Depression is a debilitating, prolonged condition that can affect eating, sleeping and every part of life. Some artists channel depression into their work, but many more live happily while drawing on a melancholy mind, recognising that joy and sorrow are inseparable. Sad music teaches us to appreciate happiness, love and compassion.
If you'd like to turn your own experiences into songs, my songwriting course is a good place to start. You might also enjoy why "Fast Car" is perfect.
