Here's the big reveal up front: my video "What Happens When I Walk Into A Guitar Store?" had 1.3 million views and earned me 82 pence through YouTube. Here's why, and why it isn't quite as bad as it looks. Figures are as I shared them at the time.
How YouTube treats music
If you use someone else's recording, YouTube's Content ID will usually spot it fast, sometimes before your video is public. You can remove it, accept the claim, or dispute it if your use is genuinely educational. Covers get picked up too, and you then share ad revenue with the rights holder on terms that heavily favour them.
That's fair, they own the copyright. But some legacy artists miss that covers are essentially free money and free promotion for them.
How I demonetised my own song
I'm completely independent: no label, no music-industry manager. But I'm running two careers at once, singer-songwriter and YouTuber, and they want different things:
- The songwriter says register every song with Content ID and collect every penny.
- The YouTuber wants to use my own songs as backing music, and wants other creators to use them too without having their videos claimed.
The guitar store video featured my song A Little Bit of Madness, which I'd released through a distributor with Content ID switched on. So my own song claimed the whole video. The revenue didn't vanish completely. It came through the distributor instead, about £300, months later and minus their share. But the claim took all of the video's revenue, not just a share for the song.
These days I release through a distributor with an annual fee, and I untick the Content ID option on every release so I can keep using my own music.
Why a million views isn't a fixed number
What a video earns depends on who's watching, where they are and how long they watch, and advertisers pay very different rates by topic. My fretless guitar video had about 1.68 million views and earned around £1,300, at an RPM of 78p. Guitar content earns much less per view than finance or tech.
That's why creators diversify: merch, sponsorships, affiliate links, courses and Patreon. And a library of videos earns over time, so you don't need every video to hit a million.
What to take from it
- Decide on purpose whether to register your songs with Content ID.
- Be careful which covers and reaction videos you invest time in.
- Don't rely on AdSense alone.
