A $99 Album: Price, Value and 1,000 True Fans

Watch A $99 Album: Price, Value and 1,000 True Fans on YouTube

Watch the video on YouTube

How much would you pay for a new album? £10 for a download? $50 for a vinyl record? Maybe you haven't bought one in years because a monthly subscription gives you unlimited access. When it comes to records, we rarely think about the difference between price and value. Since iTunes, and the streaming services that mostly replaced it, music has been devalued wholesale.

Thad Cockrell's $99 album

So I was fascinated to read that singer-songwriter Thad Cockrell had independently released his solo album The Kid for $99, including a CD, a vinyl record and a download, and wasn't putting it on streaming services. In an Instagram post he explained that making a living in music is tougher than ever, album sales don't cut it and streaming pays pennies, and that he refused to shape his music for the algorithm. He said he'd borrowed money and mortgaged his house to make it, hired the best musicians he could, and poured everything into 18 tracks. He framed it as a revolution against industry norms and a chance for fans to truly value music as art.

Please don't remortgage your house

I applaud the bravery, and Thad has an established audience. But I don't condone remortgaging your house to make a record. Loans and repayments can put real pressure on your creativity; I personally can't sleep with a financial burden like that, and I don't want any musician risking their home. It's partly why it took me seven years of making YouTube videos, after twelve years of grafting and busking, before I knew I had a fan base that would buy a physical copy of my album and help me break even.

What an album really costs

He's right about the costs, though. Having made my own record, I know album budgets are mostly musician costs, and if you want high-calibre players, you have to pay them what they deserve. Then add the years of learning your craft, the writing, the recording, manufacturing and distribution. Seen that way, $99 makes sense, and it's harder to understand how records were ever as cheap as they were. That's why artists used to need millions of fans.

1,000 true fans

Thad's campaign is a textbook example of one of my favourite ideas, Kevin Kelly's "1,000 True Fans": if 1,000 people will pay around $100 a year to support your work, you can make a good living from your art. So why give your work away on a platform that pays a pittance? It wouldn't work for someone just starting out, but for an artist with an audience, it can.

I've had far more success selling my album directly to a few thousand committed fans than I ever could have hoped for from streaming income. In fact, Thad's bundle comes to a similar total to my own vinyl, CD and download bought together. The difference is that I gave people the option to buy them separately, which still felt risky.

I expect more artists to take chances like this over the next few years. As Thad put it, if you're going to go down, go down swinging. For more, read what musicians can learn from Fender's business model and the true cost of touring, or visit my store.

Previous
Previous

Recording an Album Live, in One Take: My Approach to Songbook Volumes 3 and 4

Next
Next

What Musicians Can Learn from Fender's Business Model