Recording an Album Live, in One Take: My Approach to Songbook Volumes 3 and 4

Watch Recording an Album Live, in One Take: My Approach to Songbook Volumes 3 and 4 on YouTube

Watch the video on YouTube

At the start of the year I set myself a big goal: to make $100,000 from my original music, and to bring you into the process week by week rather than in hindsight. The first concrete step was the record itself: a double album of two acoustic records released together, Songbook Volumes 3 and 4.

A clear identity

The album has a very clear centre of gravity: me with a single instrument, mostly acoustic guitar, with no overdubs. A song might occasionally call for electric guitar or piano, but most of it lives on my custom Martin OM-42. The first Songbook was recorded on my OM-28, and having a one-off Martin with my signature in the fretboard gives this album a physical identity before you hear a note. Most of it was recorded in my own studio with gear I already owned, and once the set-up was dialled in, I left it alone: consistency and repetition, not constant tweaking.

Live, in one take

As with the earlier Songbook albums, every song is recorded live in one take. That doesn't mean one attempt; it means many takes until one feels right, but the final performance is always a complete run from start to finish. I believe a song should be able to exist on its own, with no production tricks holding it together. I know that's old-fashioned, and plenty of brilliant music lives entirely inside production. It's just not how I like my songs to live. I stand up and sing them with just a guitar, and if a song can't exist stripped back, I don't have the material.

I filmed the sessions too, but this time audio came first and video was simply documentation.

Pre-production

Pre-production meant listening back to voice memos, reading and rewriting lyrics, and working out tempos, keys and structures. I set BPMs to help my future self, but I might adjust the click as I record, because songs breathe: some days they want to push forward, others to lean back. Because I'm self-recording, preparation matters enormously. I don't want to be making basic decisions under pressure.

I aimed to record 25 to 30 songs and narrow them to two albums of around nine songs each, the shape that felt natural on the first Songbook. The songs were falling naturally into two lanes: the songwriter I used to be and the one I'm becoming. This has been a period of transition, and I don't think that needs to be hidden. I wasn't killing my darlings yet; first, each song had to survive a live recording session. I also went back through all 500 of my voice memos in case I'd missed a song. My iPhone is honestly one of my biggest songwriting tools.

Know your limits

Studio time isn't a constraint any more, but my body is. About three hours of recording a day is my maximum, because of my hands and voice. Fingerstyle playing isn't always kind to your fingertips, and repeated performances add up.

The rules

  • No overdubs.
  • No pitch correction.
  • No fixing performances after the fact. EQ, compression and reverb, yes, but nothing that pretends the performance was something it wasn't.
  • Minimal editing: choosing takes, not repairing them.

I like limitations. When something can be edited endlessly, you play differently; you rely on the safety net, and I think that often makes performances worse. I've never presented perfection on my channel, and that's intentional. I've seen some of the best musicians in the world live, once-in-a-generation voices, and not every note was in tune. That was part of the magic. I aim for a high standard, just not a sterile one.

Mixing with restraint

The goal in mixing is restraint: balance, space and tone, decisions people won't consciously notice but will feel. Even reverb matters. It can sound beautiful and expansive, but it can't be dishonest; no huge cathedral moments for no reason.

What pre-orders made possible

By the end of the first week, 452 people had pre-ordered. That number might not look big on the internet, but for an independent musician it's a game-changer. Those sales gave me runway, time and permission to do this properly.

For more on how I work, read five tips for recording vocals at home and a $99 album and 1,000 true fans. My records are available in my store.

Previous
Previous

The "Dark Horse" Lawsuit and Why It Worried Songwriters

Next
Next

A $99 Album: Price, Value and 1,000 True Fans