Plenty of people have compared expensive and affordable acoustics on YouTube, but I wanted to do it my way: with the two acoustics I actually own, playing one of my own songs over the top. This video wasn't sponsored by either company.
The affordable guitar is the Orangewood Oliver, at $225 at the time (the price had gone up since my first video about it in late 2019). The expensive one is my go-to guitar, my Martin OM-28E, at $3,799. I've had both since 2019.
The two companies
C.F. Martin & Co. is based in Nazareth, Pennsylvania, and has been family owned since Christian Frederick Martin's first guitar came off his workbench in America in 1833, with six generations steering it since. Martin's guitar making actually goes back even further, to around 1807 in Germany. The company introduced many features of the modern steel-string acoustic, including the dreadnought body and scalloped bracing. I tell the story in the birth of the American guitar.
Orangewood is a Los Angeles company founded by two brothers, which launched its first collection in 2018. The guitars are designed and set up in California, with components made in China and Indonesia, and sold online only.
The specs
Orangewood Oliver ($225):
- Solid mahogany top, laminated mahogany back and sides, natural satin finish
- 25.5-inch scale, scalloped X-bracing, no electronics
- Sonokeling rosewood bridge and fingerboard, bone nut, chrome die-cast tuners
Martin OM-28E ($3,799), for about $3,574 more:
- Spruce top, East Indian rosewood back and sides, gloss finish
- 25.4-inch scale, X-bracing, LR Baggs Anthem electronics
- Herringbone inlay, ebony bridge and fingerboard, bone nut, nickel open-gear tuners
I put the same strings on both to keep it fair.
What to watch for in a cheap guitar
Be wary of a low price tag. Luckily, my Orangewood has been great. But if a cheap guitar won't stay in tune, has sharp fret ends, buzzes or has a bad set-up, it can be uncomfortable or even unplayable, and that can put you off learning altogether. A good set-up from a guitar tech can transform an affordable instrument.
And the expensive ones: diminishing returns
At the other end there are diminishing returns. A $10,000 guitar isn't necessarily better than a $3,000 one; it may simply use more expensive, shinier materials that don't change how it plays or sounds.
The song test
I played my new song "6000 Miles" on both, because I like hearing guitars in context with a vocal. It has full chords, more open voicings, palm muting and a gentle percussive bridge, so you can hear the body of each guitar too. Percussion is an integral part of playing acoustic.
Listening back in the studio, close-miked with good microphones and a vocal on top, the difference was not that drastic. Separately, they do sound different: the Martin is warmer and sounds the way a Martin should. The Orangewood just has a different character, and in many recording situations it would sound great. In the same room you'd hear more of a difference, and things like changing strings feel very different too. But for many players, the cheaper guitar does far more than its price suggests.
If you want to make the most of whichever acoustic you own, my Fingerstyle Guitar course teaches the techniques I use on both.
