Rich Kids in Music: Money Doesn't Buy Talent, but It Buys Time

Watch Rich Kids in Music: Money Doesn't Buy Talent, but It Buys Time on YouTube

Watch the video on YouTube

Rick Beato published a video about rich kids taking over the music industry, and the conversation keeps resurfacing: the children of billionaires making records, the children of actors becoming singers, the children of producers becoming producers. Nepo babies, trust funds, private schools, famous parents. The most-liked comments under his video made the same point in different ways: it's easy to follow your dreams when you have a safety net.

"The gift of time"

The New York Times interviewed Gracie Abrams, daughter of J.J. Abrams and producer Katie McGrath, which is a bit like asking the rich kid directly. What I found fascinating is that she didn't argue with the premise. She acknowledged her privilege and her safety net, and the freedom to experiment and concentrate. And she used a phrase that I think gets to the heart of it: the gift of time.

Maybe we're having the wrong argument. Money doesn't buy talent, great songs or a career. But it absolutely buys time: time to practise, to write bad songs before the good ones, to play to empty rooms, to make a record nobody hears, to move to London, Los Angeles or New York, to meet people, to fail, and above all to try again.

I asked my newsletter readers about this and got dozens of replies from working musicians, parents, retired players and people who'd stopped. The one that stuck with me said that the truly rich person is the one who gets to decide what to do with their time: who can wake up on a Tuesday and say, "Today I'm going to make something." That's wealth too.

Why it gets under people's skin

Wealthy people have always made music. What grates is the mythology: the songwriter alone in a bedroom, the band in the garage, years of pub gigs until the songs are too good to ignore. Then you look behind the curtain and the bedroom is in a multi-million-pound house, the rent is paid, the parents know half the industry, and if the album flops nobody gets evicted.

But I don't agree with the nastier responses either. Money doesn't protect anyone from grief, heartbreak, loneliness, rejection or a dysfunctional family. You don't have to be poor to write a good song, and I don't like the romanticising of suffering, as if you have to be miserable enough before you're allowed to make meaningful art.

What money actually gives you: another go

Getting good at music takes ages. You write songs nobody cares about, play gigs nobody comes to, make a record that disappears. Your band breaks up. You spend a thousand pounds recording and pressing something and make twenty back. You drive four hours to play to 11 people. Then you have to decide whether to do it all again.

Can you afford another go? If your parents pay your rent, probably. You can take the unpaid internship, or the support tour that barely covers petrol, and anything you earn can go back into the music. None of that makes you talented, but it really helps.

The hidden advantage: knowing how it works

There's another advantage that needs no money at all: knowing how this world works. If your parents work in entertainment, you know what a manager and an agent do before you need one. You know successful creative people aren't mythical creatures; they're people who come round for dinner. You understand the vocabulary and the unwritten rules.

Why it matters

The question I care about isn't whether to be angry at any one artist. It's what happens to music when only wealthy people can afford enough time to become good at it. That's why supporting independent musicians directly, buying the record, owning the music and coming to the show, matters so much. My own records were made without that kind of safety net, and buying from my store directly helps me make the next one.

For more on the economics of an independent career, read how much money I lost on tour and what a million YouTube views really earned me.

Previous
Previous

Blue Dot Fever: Is Live Music in Trouble, or Are We Booking the Wrong Rooms?

Next
Next

Expensive vs Affordable Acoustic Guitar: My Martin OM-28E Against a $225 Orangewood