In this video I put the brand-new PRS SE Silver Sky side by side with my American-made Silver Sky in the Nebula finish. At launch the SE was around $900 and the US model around $3,500. That is a huge gap in price, and I wanted to find out how big the gap in sound really is.
I'll be honest up front: as an owner of the American-made version, I was not expecting to be this impressed by the SE.
The main spec differences
- Body wood: the SE is made of poplar rather than alder.
- Fretboard radius: the SE has an 8.5-inch radius, compared with the vintage-style 7.25 inches on the US model. This was the spec that surprised most people when PRS announced it. And, to my own surprise, I feel more comfortable on the SE neck than on my Nebula.
- Nut: the SE has a synthetic bone nut. It isn't as stable as the bone nut on the US guitar and can come loose when you change strings.
- Tuners: both have vintage-style tuners, but the SE's aren't locking.
- Pickups: the SE uses the 635JM pickups, and the pickup covers aren't colour-matched to the guitar.
- Bridge: a two-point bridge on the SE, compared with a six-point on the US model.
- Back plate: the SE has a tremolo cover on the back; the US model doesn't have one, and you can't add one.
- Finish and options: the SE launched in four colours with a rosewood fretboard only. The US Silver Sky comes in many more colours and a choice of rosewood or maple. The SE neck has a satin-like finish that I actually prefer.
There is a difference in build quality if you look closely, but it is subtle.
The sound test
To keep it fair, I put the same set of strings on both guitars. Then I played them side by side, both on their own and in a song context, singing over the top, to see whether you could tell them apart.
Listening back on good studio monitors, I kept trying to guess which guitar was coming next, and I sometimes got it wrong. There are small differences in the pickups and the overall tone, but they are very slight. In a song with a vocal on top, they mostly disappear.
My verdict
This is a classic case of diminishing returns. If you love the look and feel of the Silver Sky and want one without breaking the bank, the SE is incredible. If you just want to sit down and play a great guitar, it's arguably the perfect choice.
The US model still has the edge in hardware, the nut, and the range of finishes and options. But the gap is far smaller than the price suggests, and I'm fascinated that PRS chose to make the two so close. Thank you to PRS for sending me the SE to try.
If you want to make the most of whichever guitar you own, my Fingerstyle Guitar course covers the technique I use on electric as well as acoustic. I've also written about how a Fender Stratocaster is made if you're curious about the guitar that inspired the Silver Sky.
