I was in Chicago working with my friend Rob Scallon, so I asked him to help me with an uncomfortable experiment: comparing two performances of John Mayer's "Stop This Train", filmed eight years apart. The first was from 2010, when I was at university making YouTube videos that have since been private for years.
The performance that changed my life
I first saw Mayer play "Stop This Train" on Where the Light Is when I was about 18. I hadn't seen anyone sing and play fingerstyle like that before, and it changed everything for me. It took me a long time to learn it even to the standard of that first video, and back then I made bits up because I couldn't play all of it. I've been trying to learn it properly ever since. If you want to understand why Mayer's playing is so hard to copy, I break it down in why "Georgia" by John Mayer is so hard to play.
The nicest thing about the comparison is that I used the same guitar in both videos.
The shortcut I took in 2010
In the 2010 version I'd already chickened out by putting a capo on the fourth fret and changing the key. The proper version needs a big stretch: your thumb on the third fret of the low E string while your little finger reaches the seventh fret of the high E. Moving everything four frets up makes the stretch much shorter, but it sounded oddly high.
There's nothing wrong with using a capo to make something playable while you build up to it. Just be honest with yourself that it's a stepping stone.
Accents and lyrics
I still catch myself copying Mayer's American pronunciation because I know his recording so well. With my clearly English speaking voice, it can sound a bit strange. It's worth noticing which habits you've borrowed from the record and deciding whether you want to keep them.
Rushing when the camera is on
In the old video I changed the tempo completely, because I wasn't playing to a click. Even though it's just you and a camera, the moment you see the recording timer ticking, it's easy to rush. Rob said he does the same, especially when time is tight and you need a take straight away.
That's why I now practise to a click track, and it's good practice for anyone. One tip: if you record with a click, be careful it doesn't bleed into your microphone. I've ruined takes that way more times than I'd like to admit, which is why I now use in-ear monitors rather than headphones.
The technology then and now
The 2010 video was in standard definition, probably shot on a camcorder, with the guitar recorded direct and edited in iMovie. YouTube was a very different place, without hundreds of thousands of creators making high-quality videos. Looking back, I can't be too hard on myself: that was the best I could do at the time.
Eight years on
My new recording took far too long, plenty went wrong, and it still isn't perfect. I don't think I'll ever perfect this song, because it's genuinely challenging. But it now feels ingrained in me, and hearing the two side by side shows that the years of practice did add up. If you've been working on something for a long time, film yourself now. Your future self will thank you for the comparison.
If you want to work on this style of playing, my Fingerstyle Guitar course covers the techniques step by step.
