Why Georgia is one of my favourite John Mayer songs, and I'd never covered it because I'd never learnt it properly. It's hard. So I tried to learn it while I was actually in Atlanta, Georgia. Spoiler: four months later, I still hadn't perfected it.
Why it's deceptive
It starts with two chords almost every guitarist learns early on. Then it gets complicated, and on top of that he's singing over it at the same time. I'd been faking one tricky part of the first verse for about ten years without realising.
What I learnt in the practice room
- Look it up rather than guess. I wasted half an hour trying to work out a passage by ear before checking the chords and tabs, and realised I had the shape completely wrong.
- Listen to which notes stand out. I was hearing the higher notes in one chord most clearly, but on the record the lower part is more pronounced. Getting that balance right in the picking hand changed everything.
- The breakthrough was one finger. In my case, the little finger and where it moves next.
- Take breaks. After about 40 minutes my hand was sore. Stopping is a healthy part of practising.
Every practice session involves a minor crisis. It's the same with learning anything: you're eager, and then one small thing throws you. But tunes like this also show how much study went into his playing, and pushing yourself on them feeds straight back into your own songwriting.
The Paul Davids lesson
When I got to Germany I recruited Paul Davids to help. His main point: when you learn something, aim for the least amount of effort. Keep your hand in roughly the same position and make only small movements so you can flow between the open strings and the next shapes. For the hardest section, the trick is in the syncopated rhythm, and the only way through is slowly.
He also pointed out I'd been playing the easy bit wrong, too.
What's your Why Georgia?
Everyone has a song like this. Pick yours, slow it down and come back to it. If you want structured help, Fingerstyle Guitar for Beginners builds the right-hand independence songs like this demand.
