There's a new phrase going round the music industry: blue dot fever. It's that sinking feeling of opening a ticket map and seeing a sea of blue dots: unsold seats and whole sections nobody has booked. Over recent months we've seen major artists quietly cancel tours, move to smaller venues or postpone dates, and some have spoken openly about the pressure of touring.
I want to be clear that this isn't about criticising anyone. Touring is difficult, expensive and exhausting, and if an artist cancels, I assume the reasons are far more complicated than any of us can see. Having booked my own shows, I know how many moving parts there are: venue hire, engineers, hotels, fuel, staff, marketing, merchandise, ticketing and travel, all before anyone walks through the door. I wanted to understand whether something has genuinely changed.
What 200 of you told me
I asked my newsletter subscribers what makes them buy tickets, what stops them, and what makes a show worth leaving the house for. More than 200 people replied. You didn't all agree, but some themes came up again and again: price, too many tours chasing too few nights out, and algorithms that were meant to connect artists and audiences making it harder to reach people.
Are we creating the problem ourselves?
I also wonder whether we sometimes cause blue dot fever. Every musician dreams of bigger rooms, every promoter wants to believe demand has grown, and every agent wants the next step to be upwards. A half-empty theatre doesn't necessarily mean nobody wanted to come. It may just mean the room was too ambitious.
Social media has distorted our expectations. A song can have millions of streams and an artist hundreds of thousands of followers, but how many of them will buy a ticket? We've become very good at measuring attention. I'm not sure we're good at measuring commitment.
People who would have come, if they'd known
One email struck me. Mike, in the Bay Area, used to buy tickets as soon as they went on sale. Now he often finds out about a concert after it's happened, and thinks he'd have gone if he'd known. That isn't someone who's fallen out of love with live music. It's someone the artist never reached.
Every independent musician will recognise that. Instagram barely shows people your posts, Facebook isn't what it was, TikTok can deliver huge numbers one week and almost nothing the next, and advertising is increasingly expensive. It's strangely hard to tell people you're even playing a show.
People working in touring also told me audiences are buying later than ever, perhaps because money is tight, or they're waiting for payday, or keeping options open. If so, a blue ticket map six weeks out may not tell the whole story. People may simply buy differently now.
The middle-class musician
All this made me question whether we've been chasing the wrong definition of success. Musicians have to be a little delusional; you have to believe something statistically ridiculous is possible. But I think sustainability now matters more than scale, and there's space for something we've never really celebrated: the middle-class musician. Not struggling, not on private jets, just making a good living from music.
- Maybe success is 1,000 true fans rather than a million passive listeners.
- Maybe it's selling 1,000 records every year rather than hoping to sell a million once.
- Maybe it's building something steady enough to still exist in ten years.
Grow the room at the speed of trust
I think venue size should grow at the speed of trust, not the speed of ambition. Move up only once you've repeatedly sold out the room you're in. Selling out is psychologically powerful for everyone, while a half-full room feels disappointing even if more people actually came.
José, writing from Spain, made a great point: smaller venues create the illusion of abundance. A room that's 80% full feels exciting, with people close together and the atmosphere building naturally. The same number of people in a bigger theatre feels empty. Maybe success isn't the size of the room but how the room feels.
The relationship sells the tickets
I've never had a record label, a manager or an official booking agent. Everything I've built has happened directly with my audience. It hasn't always been easy, but it taught me something valuable: I don't think advertising sold my tickets. The relationship did.
That's why I now ask people to sign up to my newsletter and tell me where they live, so I can book shows where people actually are rather than guessing. You can see my upcoming dates on my tour page, and read more in how much money I lost on tour.
