On the surface, live music has never looked healthier. When I made this video in 2024, Live Nation, the world's largest live entertainment company, had just reported total revenue of more than $22 billion for 2023, with tens of millions of people attending its concerts. Stadium tours from the likes of Metallica and Taylor Swift were breaking records. But the reality on the ground for grassroots venues is very different, and in this video I explain why that should worry all of us.
Grassroots venues are struggling
Small venues are a vital part of the musical ecosystem, and they're under serious threat from rising operating costs, the legacy of the lockdowns, rent increases and noise complaints from new developments. The Music Venue Trust, a UK charity, reported that 125 grassroots spaces had closed or stopped hosting live music in the previous year. Its surveyed member venues staged more than 187,000 events in 2023, with close to 1.7 million individual artist performances, yet on more than £500 million in revenue they made a combined profit of about £2.5 million. That's roughly half a per cent.
Why small venues matter
An intimate club show can knock a soulless stadium out of the park for atmosphere and connection. It's where most of us learn to perform, hold a crowd and build an audience, and very few artists can jump straight to stadiums. One of the highlights of my gig-going life was seeing Katy Perry at Scala, an 800-capacity London venue, back in 2008. Nobody becomes a megastar without the playground that small venues provide when they're starting out.
I was touring eight small UK venues that autumn, and it wasn't a given that they'd all still be open when my night came around. One of them launched an urgent crowdfunding appeal days before I filmed. Crowdfunders provide temporary relief, but they're not a long-term solution. I write about my own experience of those tours in the realities of touring and the true cost of touring.
"Shouldn't venues just be better run?"
When I shared an early version of these thoughts in my newsletter, one reader made a fair point: I run my own limited company responsibly, venues should be run responsibly too, and businesses that can't pay their way shouldn't expect handouts. Some of that is valid. Venues are businesses, and businesses come and go. I'll also be honest that I rely on a very traditional form of arts support, patronage, to keep my channel running and fund projects like my albums.
But not all businesses are equal, and this crisis isn't simply the result of bad management. Many venues do extraordinary things on a shoestring. They've faced unprecedented pressures: the pandemic wiped out their reserves, energy bills rose many times over in some cases, and rents rose sharply. The arts bring social benefits and drive economic growth. A night at a gig means money for taxi drivers, bars, restaurants and babysitters, and it fosters pride in a community.
A ticket levy on big shows
One proposed solution is a small levy on tickets for large-scale shows, with the money going to support the grassroots, because otherwise, in 20 years' time, there may be no new artists left to fill arenas. The independent ticketing company Skiddle voluntarily introduced a 50p levy, paid into the Music Venue Trust's pipeline investment fund, and pledged to match what it raised, in the hope others would follow. At the time, the UK government showed little appetite for making this a requirement. Meanwhile, Birmingham, the UK's second-largest city, announced plans to cut its arts budget entirely as it struggled to make huge savings. I think that's cultural vandalism. Art is often the first thing cut, yet it gives us the events that make life worth living.
The wider economics of live music are something I dig into in blue dot fever and live music ticket sales.
How you can help
- Go and see that local artist you've heard about, or look up what's on near you.
- Buy tickets directly from the venue or artist where you can.
- Donate to venue appeals if you're able to.
- Follow the work of the Music Venue Trust.
- Write to your local representative asking them to do more for grassroots music.
Worst case, you get out of the house and away from a screen for an evening, and you might make some amazing friends. You can see where I'm playing on my tour page.
