What Genre Is My Music? Country, Folk, Rock and Why Labels Don't Matter

Watch What Genre Is My Music? Country, Folk, Rock and Why Labels Don't Matter on YouTube

Watch the video on YouTube

I often get asked what genre of music I make, and I've never had a satisfying answer. In this video I explore what I might actually be, using a little music history along the way. In his book Major Labels, the critic Kelefa Sanneh divides popular music into seven broad genres: rock, R&B, country, punk, hip-hop, dance and pop. He acknowledges that leaves out jazz, classical and Latin music, each of which could fill books of their own, and within those seven there are so many subgenres it can become overwhelming.

Am I country?

My knee-jerk answer was country, but on reflection I don't think that's right. I'm certainly very influenced by it. Growing up in the late 1990s, there was a lot of Shania Twain and the Dixie Chicks (now The Chicks) in our house, even in the small city in the south of England where I grew up. Shania Twain's fusion of country with rock and pop brought the genre to a huge international audience, and Come On Over became the best-selling country album of all time.

Country grew out of a blend of American folk, blues and church music. The 1927 recording sessions in Bristol, Tennessee, are so significant that the US Congress recognised the city as the birthplace of country music. Immigrants to the Appalachian Mountains brought music from their homes, and American folk itself drew on Celtic, European and African American traditions.

Genres are always a work in progress. Country fed rockabilly, which fed rock and roll. Later, rock and punk influences produced alt-country, which rejected the conservatism of the original in favour of something more countercultural, with artists like Wilco, Bright Eyes and Ryan Adams. Taylor Swift began as a huge country star before moving into pop. Today there's bro-country, bluegrass, Americana and, in the UK, even a West Country tongue-in-cheek style called "scrumpy and western". Katie Pruitt's album Expectations, which blends country, folk and rock, is a recent favourite of mine, and Lil Nas X's "Old Town Road" shows how far the boundaries have moved. But I'm not what a purist would call a country artist.

Am I folk?

Two of my biggest songwriting influences, Joni Mitchell and Tracy Chapman, are folk artists, or more precisely, contemporary folk, part of the second folk revival that emerged in the mid-20th century and peaked in the 1960s. I write more about them in why "Both Sides Now" is perfect and why "Fast Car" is perfect.

Traditional folk is much older. Songs evolved through oral transmission, being memorised and passed down, and they often relate to a national culture and commemorate historical or personal events. The English antiquarian William Thoms coined the word "folklore" in 1846, and one simple definition of folk is music by the people, for the people. In the 1930s it documented everyday struggles during the Great Depression; after the Second World War, the folk revival saw artists like Bob Dylan and Joni Mitchell write about civil rights and social justice, with New York's Greenwich Village as a hotbed. The UK gave us Donovan, Bert Jansch and Roy Harper; Canada, Leonard Cohen, Joni Mitchell and Neil Young; the US, Pete Seeger, Woody Guthrie and Peter, Paul and Mary. For more on that tradition, read the power of protest songs.

One of my most formative musical experiences was watching KT Tunstall perform "Black Horse and the Cherry Tree" on Later... with Jools Holland with nothing but a guitar, a tambourine and a loop pedal. You could call it folk rock or even folktronica, and it changed what I thought was possible. It's a big part of why I explain how I use a loop pedal today.

The electric side

But lots of my other influences are decidedly electric. Muse have been called alt rock, prog, space rock and pop, drawing as much on classical music as on Jimi Hendrix. Seeing Matt Bellamy play guitar was a huge moment in my deciding to become a musician, and I learned "Plug In Baby" and "Hysteria" and played them at early gigs.

John Mayer is another guitar hero. He started out as an acoustic pop artist, then leaned into the influence of Stevie Ray Vaughan, Hendrix, Clapton and BB King's string bends. He has toured as a guitarist with Dead & Company, made country-leaning records like Born and Raised and Paradise Valley, and then released the soft-rock Sob Rock. So what is he, and does it matter?

Why I've stopped worrying about genre

I think it's easy to get hung up on genres. With so much music available online, it's never been easier to be exposed to interesting music that feeds your own work. It's great to mix influences and make something new, and it's equally great to be a purist and work within a tradition. I'm not going to let it get to me: I'll write what I want, and others can decide what to call it. If you'd like to develop your own voice as a writer, my course The Craft of Songwriting is a good place to start.

Previous
Previous

The Death of Live Music? Why Grassroots Venues Need Our Help

Next
Next

Why Traditional Music Promotion Is Broken, and What to Do Instead