A Short History of Swearing in Music, and the Parental Advisory Label

Watch A Short History of Swearing in Music, and the Parental Advisory Label on YouTube

Watch the video on YouTube

In popular music there's one symbol that thrills buyers and worries their parents: the Parental Advisory: Explicit Lyrics label. My first experience of it was Blink-182's Enema of the State, which I smuggled home at 13 and hid from my parents like precious treasure. In this video I look at where that label came from, and why swearing has always been part of music.

The PMRC and the "Filthy Fifteen"

The Parents Music Resource Center, or PMRC, was formed in the US in 1983 with the aim of giving parents more control over children's access to music with violent, drug-related or sexual themes. It was founded by four women nicknamed the "Washington Wives" because of their husbands' government roles, including Tipper Gore, wife of then senator and later vice president Al Gore, and Susan Baker, wife of Treasury Secretary James Baker.

The PMRC compiled a list of the 15 songs it found most objectionable, which became known as the "Filthy Fifteen". Top of the list was Prince's "Darling Nikki" (I won't repeat the lyrics here). Madonna, Black Sabbath, Judas Priest, Mötley Crüe and Cyndi Lauper were among the others. The group even suggested letter codes for different kinds of content: V for violence, O for occult themes, D/A for drugs and alcohol.

Under pressure, by August 1985, 19 record companies had agreed to add warning labels. Album covers from Def Leppard, Wendy O. Williams and W.A.S.P., and music videos by Van Halen and Twisted Sister, were presented as evidence of rock music's role in the decline of American society.

The Senate hearing

Three musicians testified against what they saw as censorship. Dee Snider of Twisted Sister calmly introduced himself as a married father, a Christian who didn't drink, smoke or take drugs, and the writer of songs consistent with those beliefs. Frank Zappa dismissed the proposal as ill-conceived nonsense that infringed the civil liberties of adults and would open the door to endless moral policing. John Denver compared it to book burning and argued it would backfire, because whatever is forbidden becomes the thing people want most.

We all know he was right. Label something forbidden and it instantly becomes more appealing, especially if you're a teenager looking to rebel.

Even so, the Recording Industry Association of America agreed in November 1985 to put advisory labels on selected releases. The standardised black-and-white label followed, and 2 Live Crew's 1990 album Banned in the USA is often cited as the first to carry it. Within a couple of years, hundreds of records had been labelled. Label executives began exercising more control over what artists could say, and big retailers like Walmart demanded clean versions or refused to stock albums.

Artists fought back. At Lollapalooza in 1993, Rage Against the Machine stood naked on stage for around 14 minutes with duct tape over their mouths and "PMRC" written on their chests, without playing a note. Guns N' Roses put their own mock warning sticker on Use Your Illusion I and II, telling offended listeners where to go. The PMRC faded away in the 1990s, which is probably just as well, given what's in the charts today.

Swearing is nothing new

A study of American books found that readers in the late 2000s were far more likely to encounter swear words than readers in the early 1950s. One explanation is that as society becomes more individualistic, we place more value on self-expression, and swear words can carry real emotional weight.

But swearing has been part of human culture for thousands of years:

  • Archaeologists have found rude graffiti on the walls of Pompeii, and the historian John Landels has noted that bawdy songs full of obscene language were sung at parties in ancient Greece and Rome.
  • Melissa Mohr's Holy Sh*t: A Brief History of Swearing shows how offensive language has changed. In medieval times, swearing "by God's bones" was about the worst thing you could say.
  • Mozart, one of the greatest composers who ever lived, filled his letters and some of his canons with crude toilet humour.
  • In the early 20th century, risqué songs were recorded for the amusement of engineers or sold privately as party records.

"Louie Louie" and the FBI

The Kingsmen's 1963 recording of "Louie Louie" was so hard to make out that people assumed it was hiding obscene lyrics. The FBI investigated for around two years before concluding that the words were simply unintelligible. The reality was a rushed, under-rehearsed session with a tired singer shouting over the band. Hilariously, the investigators missed the one genuine slip: just before the one-minute mark, the drummer drops a stick and swears loudly enough to be faintly heard.

Similarly, in 1968 some radio stations in El Paso, Texas, banned Bob Dylan's records because they couldn't make out his words, yet happily played other artists' covers of his songs.

Why I rarely swear in my own songs

These days, songs without swearing are the exception in the charts, and sometimes it really works. I've enjoyed plenty of brilliantly explicit songs while researching this.

I've only sworn in one of my own songs. I want the freedom to use whatever language best expresses what I mean. But the more often you use these words, the less power they have. So I keep that language to a minimum in my own work, so that when it lands, it really lands.

If you're thinking about word choice in your own lyrics, my songwriting course goes into how I approach lyrics. For more music history, read about Robert Johnson or the rise of Led Zeppelin.

Previous
Previous

Writing Songs About Real People: Breakup Songs, Ethics and the Law

Next
Next

Why Some of Us Can't Wake Up at 5am: Night Owls and Creativity