Writing Songs About Real People: Breakup Songs, Ethics and the Law

Watch Writing Songs About Real People: Breakup Songs, Ethics and the Law on YouTube

Watch the video on YouTube

Breakups are no fun. They shatter the life you imagined, they're often drawn out, and they can be expensive, especially if you live together or are married. But if you're a songwriter, there's an upside: with luck, heartbreak unlocks some of your best material. Fleetwood Mac, ABBA, Adele, Carole King, Marvin Gaye, Bon Iver, the Mamas & the Papas and Alanis Morissette have all put heartbreak to good use. So if you meet a songwriter, approach with caution.

Famous songs about famous people

Carly Simon's "You're So Vain" is a classic written about a composite of three past lovers. In 2015 she confirmed that the second verse is about Warren Beatty, adding that he thinks the whole song is about him.

There's something tantalising about decoding famous lyrics about other famous people, but it can make a bad situation messier. Around the time I made this video, Fletcher released "Becky's So Hot", a power-pop anthem about fancying your ex's new partner, and the real Becky was easy to identify online. Would you see that as unfair, or as a compliment?

Then there's "Layla". Eric Clapton's love for Pattie Boyd, then married to George Harrison, produced one of the most famous guitar riffs ever. Pattie later divorced George and married Eric, though that still didn't end happily ever after.

Should you ask permission?

Speaking from personal experience, I'm not sure my exes would have given permission if I'd asked, in which case I wouldn't have released anything at all. So before finishing my debut album, I asked Devin Stone of LegalEagle a simple question: could a songwriter be sued by the person who inspired a song?

The legal answer: defamation

Here's my summary of what Devin explained. (I'm not a lawyer, and this isn't legal advice for your situation.)

  • A song is like any other art. It can be pure fiction or tell the real story of something that happened.
  • Contracts aside, such as a non-disclosure agreement, the main legal risk is defamation.
  • Defamation requires a provably false statement about someone that harms their reputation. Your opinion of someone, or obvious exaggeration, generally isn't defamation. You'd effectively have to lie about a real person in a damaging way.
  • Not naming them isn't automatically a defence. Under "defamation by implication", if listeners know who you mean, a false and damaging statement can still count. Devin pointed to the Johnny Depp and Amber Heard case, where she didn't name him in a newspaper article but everyone knew who she meant.
  • But truth and opinion are generally safe. If you're describing what actually happened, or your opinion of someone you broke up with, it's unlikely to be defamatory. And if nobody can tell who the song is about, a claim would be very difficult.

The ethics are up to you

Social media adds a dimension earlier songwriters didn't have to deal with: fans can identify, find and message the real people behind songs. My own songs have been called confessional, and my exes might assume certain songs are about them, but I'd never name and shame anyone. For me, keeping my private life private, even while working online, comes down to personal morality.

Joni Mitchell and Graham Nash

To me, Joni Mitchell and Graham Nash were the most iconic couple of the 1960s. Nash has described the night they got together: she played him a string of the best songs he'd ever heard. He moved into her house in Laurel Canyon, and "Our House" captured their early domestic bliss.

It didn't last. She famously ended things by telegram, with a line about how sand held too tightly runs through your fingers. Much of Blue was written about the breakup, with "River" and "My Old Man" among its highlights. Nash answered with songs of his own, and Neil Young wrote "Only Love Can Break Your Heart" partly to console his bandmate. Nash has said he feels lucky to have spent that time with Joni, and that they both got some good songs out of it.

And Taylor Swift

Taylor Swift is the undisputed queen of the breakup song. Harry Styles gets off fairly lightly in "Style", while "Dear John" is widely understood to be about her short relationship with John Mayer.

If you're turning your own experiences into songs, my songwriting course covers how I write honestly without oversharing. You might also like my article on what makes "Dreams" by Fleetwood Mac perfect, a breakup song written within the band.

Previous
Previous

What a Million Views on YouTube Really Earned Me: RPM, CPM and Watch Time

Next
Next

A Short History of Swearing in Music, and the Parental Advisory Label