Quit Your Job, Start a Band: The Strokes and New York's Last Rock and Roll Moment

Watch Quit Your Job, Start a Band: The Strokes and New York's Last Rock and Roll Moment on YouTube

Watch the video on YouTube

Meet Me in the Bathroom is a 2023 documentary based on Lizzy Goodman's 2017 book, the definitive account of New York's music scene at the turn of the millennium, when The Strokes, Interpol, the Yeah Yeah Yeahs and LCD Soundsystem reshaped American indie music. Goodman moved to New York in 1999 and met a colleague, Nick Valensi, who said he played guitar in a band that was just starting out. They were called The Strokes.

A moment before everything changed

Like California in the late 1960s, it was a group of like-minded friends who hung out, formed bands and caught the world's attention. Goodman describes it as the calm before the storms of the new millennium: 9/11, the remaking of New York, and the arrival of the iPod, Facebook and Twitter. For a few magical years, everyone was chasing New York, and they caught it.

It may have been the last rock and roll happening of its kind, right on the cusp of mass internet adoption. Record sales were healthy, MTV still had huge audiences, the music press sold hundreds of thousands of magazines a week, and rent in places like Brooklyn was still relatively cheap, with plenty of warehouse space. What struck me most about the film is how young these bands were, in their early twenties, making incredible art while having the time of their lives. Their hedonism only grew after 9/11, when tomorrow no longer felt guaranteed. So why not quit your job and start a band?

Why the UK mattered

In the 1990s guitar music's centre of gravity had moved west, to Seattle and Los Angeles. Grunge had peaked and given way to nu metal, and in the UK bands like Coldplay and Travis dominated the radio. Then the British music press, especially NME, heavily promoted the new wave of New York bands, even putting The Strokes on the cover before they'd released a single. I first learned about them reading my older brother's copies.

Julian Casablancas told NME that without British fans, he'd still be working in a bar. When Is This It came out in the UK in late August 2001, young Brits fell for these stylish New Yorkers. It reached number two in the UK album chart, the band were headlining festivals within months, and the album was named the best of 2001 by multiple publications.

Gordon Raphael's story

I spoke to producer Gordon Raphael, who recorded Is This It at his Transporterraum studio in Manhattan's East Village, about his memoir and how he met the band. He arrived in New York in 1998, set up a studio to record his own music, and when his money ran out, bands started asking him to record them.

In autumn 2000 he went to a gig at the Luna Lounge. He loved the first band and gave them his card. Then a very young, very stylish band played to about 45 people. He admits he didn't really get their music that night, but as the guitarists packed up their pedals, he told them he had a studio nearby and did cheap demos. Albert Hammond Jr. came to see it, liked it, and ran home to tell Julian they should record there. That demo became The Modern Age EP, and within months there was enormous excitement about it.

The lesson for musicians? Many of the scenes that go on to matter to millions felt completely ordinary to the people inside them at the time. Say yes, play the shows, and make the demo.

For more music history, read how Green Day took punk mainstream and how Gen X changed music.

Previous
Previous

How to Start Making Money as a Musician: Four Rules That Worked for Me

Next
Next

The Art of Outrage: Five Moments When Music Caused a Scandal