Rock and roll has been called loud, brash, vulgar and a threat to the nation's youth. Frank Sinatra dismissed it in the harshest terms, and in 1956 a Melody Maker critic called it one of the most terrifying things ever to happen to popular music. With hindsight those reactions seem hysterical. But provoking just the right amount of outrage can be one of the most valuable marketing tools an artist has. Here are five pivotal moments that caused a stir.
1. The Rite of Spring, Paris, 1913
On 29 May 1913, Igor Stravinsky's The Rite of Spring premiered at the Théâtre des Champs-Élysées as the score to a ballet for Sergei Diaghilev's company. The audience was split between wealthy traditionalists and younger bohemians who loved the experimental. Stravinsky's score subverted tonality, metre, rhythm and stress, used harsh dissonance and stacked different rhythms on top of one another (polyrhythm). To that audience it was an act of musical violence. People shouted at the stage and at each other, and some reportedly threw objects at the orchestra, who carried on regardless.
Critics were scathing, and Puccini called it the work of a madman. Accounts of the riot have grown more dramatic over the years, but the piece became iconic. Leonard Bernstein called it the most important piece of music of the 20th century, and the musicologist Thomas Forrest Kelly called its premiere the single most important moment in 20th-century music. Outrage turned into adoration.
2. Elvis's hips, 1956
When 21-year-old Elvis Presley performed on television in 1956, his gyrations were an unwelcome intrusion into millions of socially conservative American homes. Newspapers called the performance untalented, vulgar and suggestive. Famously, he was later filmed only from the waist up. It didn't stop him. Elvis became a pillar of American culture and has sold over a billion records, yet near the end of his life he reportedly confided that he didn't think he'd done anything lasting.
3. Dylan goes electric, 1965 to 1966
By 1965 Bob Dylan was the hero of the folk revival, hailed as the voice of his generation. But folk's restrictions didn't suit him, and, inspired by the Beatles, he went electric. Hardcore folk fans saw it as selling out. The controversy began at the 1965 Newport Folk Festival, where he was said to have electrified half the audience and electrocuted the other half.
On 17 May 1966, at Manchester's Free Trade Hall, he played a solo acoustic first half, then an electric second half with the Hawks. In a lull, someone famously shouted "Judas!". Dylan called him a liar and told the band to play it loud as they launched into "Like a Rolling Stone". As the folk purists feared, his new direction brought him a far bigger audience. Folk became folk rock and influenced a whole generation, and the concert became one of the defining moments of 20th-century music.
4. Ozzy and the bat, 1982
On 20 January 1982 in Des Moines, Iowa, touring Diary of a Madman, Ozzy Osbourne was in the habit of pelting audiences with raw meat, and the audience threw things back. Someone threw a bat on stage. Ozzy, assuming it was rubber, bit into it, and quickly discovered it wasn't. He had to have rabies shots. The incident became a symbol of rock and roll depravity for those who feared its influence on young people, yet he went on to sell over 100 million records and be inducted into the Rock & Roll Hall of Fame twice.
5. Madonna, "Justify My Love", 1990
Madonna's "Justify My Love", co-written with Lenny Kravitz and Ingrid Chavez, became her ninth Billboard number one. But its black-and-white video, directed by Jean-Baptiste Mondino, caused outrage for its brief nudity and erotic themes, and MTV banned it. On television, Madonna challenged the double standard of a culture happy for children to watch graphic violence but shocked by consenting adults showing affection. She then released the video on VHS, and it became the best-selling video single of all time. Audiences, it turns out, love a little scandal.
For more on music and controversy, read the history of swearing in music and what if MTV never existed?
