How Gen X "Ruined" Music, and Transformed It

Watch How Gen X "Ruined" Music, and Transformed It on YouTube

Watch the video on YouTube

Forgive me for the title. I don't actually think Generation X ruined music. It's irony, which (as every Gen Xer knows) was practically invented by Alanis Morissette in 1995. Gen X can lay claim to some of the finest musicians in history: Nirvana, Tupac, the Smashing Pumpkins, Sinéad O'Connor, the Notorious B.I.G., Alice in Chains, Snoop Dogg, Blur, Radiohead, Elliott Smith, PJ Harvey, Pearl Jam and many more. But they also changed the music industry, for better and worse. (This video was sponsored by DistroKid.)

After my video on boomer nostalgia, comment after comment pointed out that I'd left Gen X out, which they said was very on brand for the "ignored generation". So it's their turn.

The latchkey generation

Gen X are usually defined as people born between 1965 and 1980, a much smaller generation than the boomers or millennials. They lived through recessions and the dotcom boom, were the first with personal portable music like the Walkman, and the first to socialise online, while still remembering life before it. Gen Xers went on to found tech companies that revolutionised music, from file-sharing services to platforms like YouTube and MySpace.

They grew up after the peace-and-love era, realising their parents' utopian ideals hadn't changed the world much. Divorce rates rose sharply, and with parents often out at work, they became latchkey kids. That early independence, making your own sandwich after school, translated into a strong do-it-yourself mentality. Despite founding more start-ups than any other generation, they were unfairly labelled slackers.

Kings and queens of DIY

Gen X weren't the first to self-release, but they were the kings and queens of DIY culture. Hardcore punk, hip-hop, UK indie and jungle all decided that if the majors weren't interested, they'd do it themselves. They were socially conscious and more accepting of difference, and faced with an uncertain future, their songwriting turned introspective and political. They rejected the good-time party rock of hair metal in favour of grunge's darker nihilism and politically charged genres like rap and hardcore.

They weren't afraid to take on corporations either. Pearl Jam challenged Ticketmaster over the high booking fees charged to their fans, and when it wouldn't compromise, the band walked away, reportedly at a cost of around two million dollars.

Did they ruin the music industry?

If "ruin" means reducing something to collapse, then in a sense they did ruin the traditional music industry, and transformed it too:

  • Technology: they pioneered the technologies that changed how we listen and ushered in file sharing (though millennials like me have to share the blame for the downloading).
  • Eclectic taste: file sharing and a thriving college radio scene widened tastes. A Gen Xer might enjoy power pop, avant-garde electronica and British new wave in a single day, mixing genres rather than staying in one lane.
  • Sampling: hip-hop and electronic producers turned turntables and samplers into instruments, and genres like Detroit techno emerged as the technology became affordable. So when boomers complain that nobody plays real instruments, point them towards Gen X.
  • The guitar solo: it's often said that grunge killed it. Not quite, but it moved away from 1980s shredding towards a looser, earthier style, and replaced high falsetto vocals and tales of parties with darker, introspective lyrics.
  • More gender equality: alternative rock, shoegaze and riot grrrl, with bands like Bikini Kill, the Breeders and My Bloody Valentine, brought more women to the fore after a very male-dominated era.

For more on how generations argue about music, read why new music "sucks" and the birth of music piracy.

Previous
Previous

How Green Day and The Offspring Took Punk Mainstream

Next
Next

My Problem with Boomer Nostalgia: Was Music Really Better Back Then?