Have you heard the phrase "if you don't ask, you don't get"? It's a philosophy worth living by. In the summer of 2023, I emailed John Illsley, founding member and bassist of Dire Straits, who had just published his memoir My Life in Dire Straits (which I highly recommend). I didn't expect a reply, and was amazed when he invited me to his pub, the East End Arms in the New Forest. Yes, once the band called it a day, he fulfilled a long-held dream of becoming a pub landlord.
A very good day
I'm a huge Dire Straits fan, so getting to spend a few hours with John, hear his story, see his platinum records and the bass that accompanied him to some of the world's biggest shows, including Live Aid and the Nelson Mandela 70th Birthday Tribute, was a real thrill. He showed me the bass he's used on almost every album recording, played through a little Ampeg Portaflex, and told me the strings hadn't been changed since 1985. Dead, worn-in strings, and it still sounds gorgeous.
I was a bit nervous, but John was incredibly welcoming and generous with his time, and even invited us back to his music room for a jam. I can't do Mark Knopfler's guitar parts justice, but we bashed our way through.
Saying yes to chance
John is the ultimate example of someone who lived an amazing life because he took a few risks. It could all so easily have been different. After school he got a job at a timber company and was quickly put on the management scheme, with a good salary and a company credit card. But he knew that life wasn't for him, so he moved to London to study sociology at Goldsmiths as a mature student.
The flat in Deptford
He couldn't really afford the rent on his run-down flat in Deptford, south-east London, so he needed a flatmate. Through a mutual friend, David Knopfler moved in, carrying a guitar, and they became close friends. A few weeks later, David's brother Mark came to visit. John told me he came home very late, or very early, one morning to find Mark asleep on the floor with his head on the flat's only chair, a Les Paul Junior across his stomach. Over a cup of tea, they discovered a shared love of Elvis, JJ Cale, Chuck Berry and reggae, and John had a feeling he'd know this man for a long time.
John was playing in a blues trio at Goldsmiths, and Mark was in a rockabilly band in Essex. When that band's bassist needed time off, John stepped in. Soon they were jamming in the flat, and one night in the pub they decided to put something together. They needed a drummer, and Mark knew one: Pick Withers. John told me that within about ten minutes of playing together it all locked tight, and he thought: I'm playing with a proper drummer now. That was the rhythm section of Dire Straits.
From council flat to stadiums
In just a few years, Dire Straits went from a run-down flat and moving furniture for beer money to sold-out stadium tours and some of the biggest-selling records of the decade. They were one of the biggest bands of the 1980s and one of the most successful British groups ever, and they bowed out gracefully when the time felt right, which many bands could learn from. But fame is a pressure cooker. As the shows got bigger, the walls closed in: Mark and David's relationship broke down, and the band later lost its original drummer and replacement guitarist too.
For more on the band's music, read why "Sultans of Swing" is perfect and the story of Brothers in Arms.
The full documentary
To do the story justice, I made a full-length documentary, The Dire Straits Story, featuring more of John's recollections and my personal journey through the band's complete body of work. It's available on Nebula, the creator-owned streaming service I co-own with other creators, alongside other long-form projects of mine. You can read about another band's story in the rise of Led Zeppelin.
