Nerina Pallot: The Songwriter Who Changed My Life with One Question

Watch Nerina Pallot: The Songwriter Who Changed My Life with One Question on YouTube

Watch the video on YouTube

On 5 July 2005, my mum took me to Salisbury City Hall to see Suzanne Vega, with support from an artist called Nerina Pallot. I was completely blown away. She held the whole room spellbound, and not only was she an incredible singer and guitarist, she played piano in a virtuosic way I'd never seen in pop music. I queued at the merch table to buy her CD and told her I played guitar and piano and wanted to be just like her. Then she asked a question that I genuinely think changed my life: "Do you write your own songs?"

Not yet, I said. But that night I went home, picked up my guitar and wrote my first original song, which I still perform. For her it was one of a hundred interactions that evening; for me it was pivotal. When I think about my career, I often ask myself what Nerina would do. Two decades after her debut, she's still making great music, entirely independently, with a loyal and committed fan base. Recently she invited me to her home studio to talk about songwriting, the industry, mental health, management, touring and Top of the Pops.

An expensive failure

In 2001, Nerina released her debut, Dear Frustrated Superstar, on Polydor. Despite respectable reviews and the inevitable comparisons to Alanis Morissette, it didn't chart, and she and the label parted ways. She described it to me as an expensive failure: a good record, not a great one, neither commercial enough to go the distance nor quirky enough to build an artistic following. The indie press didn't know what to make of it, and the pop press didn't admit her to the pop pantheon.

She feared her career was over before it had begun. But her publisher, whom she's worked with for more than two decades, kept believing in her and told her that what she was writing next was much better. The songs that would rescue her career were born of failure, disappointment and trying to figure things out.

Fires, funded independently

Her publisher provided an advance for her second album, and when that didn't cover the costs, she used loans and credit cards to finish it. Until then, she told me, everything had come easily: scholarships, praise, a label paying for her to record in America. The rude awakening showed her that business-class flights weren't what made her tick. Her songs were, and seeing people sing them back.

Fires was released independently in 2005. Nerina toured solo and as a support act, and she used a new site called Facebook to invite fans of artists like Tori Amos to her shows. That's how I came to buy a copy. "Sapphire" remains one of my all-time favourite songs. The album then got picked up by Warner's 14th Floor Records, who remixed and re-released it with added strings. "Everybody's Gone to War" reached number 14 in the UK, "Sapphire" was nominated for an Ivor Novello award, and she was nominated for a BRIT Award for British Female Solo Artist. That one went to Amy Winehouse, and there's no shame in losing to that astonishing talent.

Careful what you wish for

She also fulfilled a childhood dream of appearing on Top of the Pops. At five, she'd told her mum that's what she'd do with her life. But on the day, she was told five minutes beforehand that she'd be performing live to track, and the monitoring was so poor she couldn't hear herself. She remembers being terrified that she must sound awful in front of the nation. Afterwards, there was no glamorous dressing-room hang; she went home alone, devastated. It's a sobering story about how television often treats music.

Managing herself

Around the time of the Ivor Novellos, her manager quit. Nerina was hurt but, looking back, understands that her manager probably expected a fortune that didn't materialise. Left with radio, TV and European commitments, she and her husband figured it out together. She met other managers but never found one who believed in her as much as she did, or who would care at 3am that the artwork wasn't right. I write about the realities of handling everything yourself in the realities of touring.

Choosing honesty over formula

After touring Fires, she completed a degree in English literature to improve her lyric writing, then released The Graduate on her own label. Some critics felt moving away from the successful formula was a mistake, and she scrapped an album's worth of material co-written with pop hitmakers because it didn't feel truthful. She said she'd realised she was more honest, and wrote her best songs, on her own. I really respect that; compromising for airplay would have been the easy path.

Her 2011 album Year of the Wolf, on Geffen, was produced by Bernard Butler with her husband and collaborator Andy Chatterley. Its opener was originally intended for Kylie Minogue, for whom Nerina has also written. She told me writing for other artists gives her an outlet for darker pop ideas that are nothing like her own records.

Listening to fans

With a young child, and tired of the record-tour cycle, she set herself a challenge in 2014: a year of recording 12 EPs of five songs each. Guided by fan feedback, much like my own Songbook releases, the best tracks plus three new songs became the album The Sound and the Fury. She told me she'd rather listen to fans than a label, because fans are effectively your customers, and they tell you what they value: the words, the sense of belonging to a little club, the niche. There's nothing to be ashamed of in a niche; all humans want to belong to one. I explore that idea in why fame is overrated.

Don't waste any time

She's since released Stay Lucky and I Don't Know What I'm Doing, balancing touring with family. She's exactly the artist I want to be: someone who can live a normal life, make music, play shows and connect with fans without a punishing world tour. She told me that before one of her annual Christmas shows, she lost her voice completely; her support act carried half the set and fans sang her songs for her. It became one of her favourite gigs, but it frightened her into resolving not to waste any more time.

Nerina, thank you for everything. The full hour-long interview is on Nebula, and if you're inspired to start writing yourself, my course The Craft of Songwriting is a good first step.

Previous
Previous

Do One Thing Every Day That Scares You: My Path to Full-Time Music

Next
Next

Why Do British Singers Sound American When They Sing?