Why Fame Is Overrated: In Praise of Being Niche Famous

Watch Why Fame Is Overrated: In Praise of Being Niche Famous on YouTube

Watch the video on YouTube

The other night I went to see my friend Adam Neely's band Sungazer. I love his videos, and I enjoy a complex time signature with the best of them, so it was a great night: a room of around 400 music nerds rocking out in 7/8, thrilled to be there. On the way home I started thinking about how fame has changed, and that's what this video is about.

Niche famous

To the people in that room, Adam is a king. But he can leave the gig and go about his business as a normal person. He makes his living from his passion, and if someone recognises him, the interaction is probably pleasant, respectful, maybe even fun. He's niche famous: well respected in his field, able to draw a decent crowd, and kept grounded by a fairly conventional life. That seems to me both very desirable and very manageable.

The pull of fame

Fame is still a highly sought-after status. Deep down, many of us want a little attention and adoration, and that desire might make you pick up a guitar, write a song or set up a camera and tripod. When I was young I dreamed of being a pop star, and in my imagination the crowd was always huge, because bigger is better, right? I don't think that way any more. The more we learn about how isolating and destructive fame can be, the less appealing it looks. Humans are pack animals; when you're singled out and treated differently by everyone around you, it can take a real toll.

The price of superstardom

Look at Chappell Roan, a hugely talented songwriter whose star rose incredibly fast. Her music has touched many people who feel deeply connected to her, but she has spoken publicly about losing the ordinary things that grounded her, like walking in her local park or going shopping, without security or a disguise, and about fans turning up at her family's doors. That sounds really challenging, and she'd only been super famous for a matter of months.

Mitski has described in interviews how fame can turn an artist into a place where strangers project all their feelings, from a need for love to anger, and the fear that comes with that. Taylor Swift, one of the most famous people in the world, needs complex security arrangements just to move through a city, and has said fame has isolated her, making it hard to meet anyone without wondering what they want from her. At that level, you're at the centre of a huge machine you can't control, and everyone around you depends on you for a living. Robin Williams once said, in essence, that being alone isn't the worst thing in life; being surrounded by people who make you feel alone is.

And yes, I hear you. It's easy to roll your eyes at millionaires complaining about their mansions when you're living paycheque to paycheque, and I'm aware of the irony of a YouTuber saying so. This isn't about feeling sorry for the rich. It's about how fame works. I explore the human cost of the industry more in the dark side of ambition.

How fame has changed

Before the internet became so central to our lives, fame mostly happened to you. You sought it out by sending a demo, but others called the shots on how big you became, and as big businesses, their priority was the bottom line. If you were the one artist on their roster who connected with the public, they'd put everything into making you as big as possible.

The monoculture era, when everyone knew The Beatles or Michael Jackson or watched the same sitcoms, has given way to a fractured cultural landscape. There are still A-listers, but there's also a generation of people who have built huge audiences almost entirely on their own. You can be immensely famous online, with millions of subscribers, and completely unknown to the average person on the street. "Influencer" isn't a term I love; "creator" I do. Someone once coined "niche internet micro-celebrity", which makes me laugh.

Why I like the niche

An online following doesn't necessarily translate into uncontrollable real-world fame, and in many ways I'm still in control. Nobody has me under contract, I don't have years of fixed commitments ahead, and I could step off the ride if I chose to. Realistically, as an independent artist who values my freedom, I'm unlikely to be catapulted to global superstardom without a major label juggernaut behind me. I talk about that choice in why I gave up on the record label dream.

Filling a 70,000-capacity stadium night after night used to be my dream. Now it sounds like a nightmare. So this is a celebration of the niche. It's a good place to be. If you'd like to stay in touch, my newsletter is the best way.

Previous
Previous

How Video Changed My Music Career: Making Music Videos on No Budget

Next
Next

My 2026 Experiment: Can I Make $100,000 from My Music Independently?