In 2019, a US jury decided that Katy Perry's 2013 hit "Dark Horse" had copied "Joyful Noise", a 2008 Christian rap track by an artist called Flame, and awarded around $2.8 million. Rick Beato and Adam Neely had already argued brilliantly against the verdict, and I agreed with them. As a professional singer-songwriter with a music degree and an interest in musicology, I found it genuinely nerve-racking. I'm not a lawyer, just an armchair detective, but I wanted to join the conversation.
The case
The claim originally sought around $20 million, and even though it centred on the instrumental riff, all six songwriters were held accountable, including those who wrote only lyrics or a rap verse. Flame's side also argued that "Dark Horse" had harmed his reputation as a Christian artist through imagery in its music video. I struggled to see why that was relevant to whether music was copied. Capitol Records bore the largest share of the damages, with smaller amounts for Perry and her co-writers.
It's easy to say, "They can afford it." The real question is what precedent it sets for songwriters who can't.
The music
When you write the rhythms of the two tracks down, they're completely different. "Joyful Noise" runs at about 154 BPM and "Dark Horse" at about 132, and they're in different keys. The two riffs might sound vaguely similar at first, but written out they differ, and the phrase isn't original anyway: it's an evenly spaced, repeated pattern of a couple of notes. As Perry's attorney put it, that's unprotectable expression, the basic building blocks or "alphabet" of music, which should be available to everyone.
The numbers
Flame's attorneys argued that because the riff plays through 45% of "Dark Horse", they deserved 45% of its earnings. By my count, the riff appears unchanged in 50 of 119 bars, closer to 42%. The jury instead decided the riff was responsible for 22.5% of the song's success. How do you determine that? A huge part of the song's success was surely that it was sung by one of the century's biggest pop stars, backed by an enormous marketing campaign.
Similarity isn't always theft
Perry had faced comparisons before. When "Roar" came out in 2013, people noted its similarity to Sara Bareilles's "Brave", released a few months earlier. Bareilles brushed it off, said they were friends and had talked about it, and didn't feel anything had been taken from her artistically. Pop songs share themes, chord progressions and rhythms all the time. That's how music works.
I also noticed that Perry's "Never Really Over" credited nine songwriters, because her team approached the Norwegian artist Dagny about similarities with her 2017 song "Love You Like That" and credited her.
How it ended
For anyone reading this now: in 2020 a judge overturned the jury's verdict, ruling that the elements in question weren't protectable, and in 2022 a federal appeals court upheld that decision. It was a relief for songwriters, but the case still shows how vulnerable musicians can feel when basic musical ideas end up in court.
For more on songwriting and the law, read writing songs about real people and cover songs, copyright and money on YouTube. (I'm not a lawyer, and none of this is legal advice.)
