$50 vs $500 Microphone: Shure PGA58 vs KSM8 Compared

Watch $50 vs $500 Microphone: Shure PGA58 vs KSM8 Compared on YouTube

Watch the video on YouTube

In this episode of Tuesday Talks, I compared a roughly $50 microphone with a roughly $500 one. If you want a proper blind test, watch the song section of the video before reading on.

The two microphones

Shure PGA58: the affordable option, at around $50 or £60 when I made the video. It has a matte black finish, a rounded grille and a small on/off switch.

Shure KSM8 Dualdyne: around $500, aimed at professional engineers and performers. It has a nickel finish, a flatter grille and a dual-diaphragm design intended to greatly reduce the proximity effect, the bass boost you get when singing very close to a mic. It's also built to be dent- and water-resistant, though I didn't test either of those.

How I tested them

I talked into each, then performed one of my songs through both, keeping the environment as similar as I could. I also tried them on a guitar amp. I'm aware vocal mics aren't designed for guitar cabs, but when you're on a low budget and just want to record, you use what you have.

What I found

  • The PGA58's build quality felt surprisingly close to the more expensive mic.
  • It coped impressively with the guitar amp, and at its price it's cheaper than the industry-standard SM58.
  • The KSM8 is undoubtedly the better microphone: more versatile and incredibly detailed. It's my own live vocal mic, and I've found it does far more than an SM58 in a live environment.

Both are remarkable in their own way. The KSM8 is a beautiful professional tool that I'll keep using live. But the fact that you could buy two PGA58s for the price of an SM58, or about ten for the price of a KSM8, is remarkable. I was even tempted to get a set to keep around the studio, so I could mic up lots of sources at once. This wasn't a sponsored video.

Which should you buy?

If you're just starting out, gigging at open mics or building a home studio on a budget, an affordable dynamic mic like the PGA58 will serve you well. If you're performing regularly and want more detail, clarity and consistency, a premium vocal mic is worth saving for. Either way, technique and placement matter as much as the price tag. For more, read my five tips for recording vocals at home, my guide to recording with Neumann U87s and why open mic nights matter.

Previous
Previous

Tiny Phone Microphone vs Pro Studio: Shure MV88+ vs AKG C414

Next
Next

Producing My Song Ride With You in Ableton with Rachel K Collier