What lessons do you learn in a lifetime? If you're lucky enough to have a career that spans decades, the songs you wrote in your twenties might come to seem naive. Or they can gain new power, finding a deeper meaning as you grow alongside them. "Both Sides Now" is the perfect example.
Clouds from both sides
Joni Mitchell was just 23 when she wrote it. Her first husband, Chuck Mitchell, had given her Saul Bellow's novel Henderson the Rain King, and on a plane she read a passage about being the first generation to see clouds from both sides: people used to dream upwards, and now they dream both upwards and downwards. When she landed, she picked up a guitar and started writing.
The music
Joni played it in an open tuning, D A D F# A D, with a capo at the fourth fret, which puts it in F# major. The song uses a modified I-IV-V progression. If you've never explored open tunings, they're a big part of why Joni's guitar parts sound the way they do; I cover a few easy ones in my lessons.
A refrain that deepens
The lyrics are built around a repeated idea that shifts through the song, moving from clouds to love to life itself and becoming emotionally deeper each time. Then the closing lines upend all of those hard-won lessons with a confession that she doesn't really know life at all. That's a brilliant songwriting device: a repeated structure where each return carries more weight.
Introducing the song at a club in Leicester in 1967, Joni described it as being about two sides of things: reality and fantasy, enchantment and disenchantment, what we're taught to believe things are and what they really are.
Several lifetimes by 23
By her early twenties Joni had already learned some of life's hardest lessons. Childhood polio left her bedridden and isolated for months, afraid she'd never walk again, a terrible prospect for an enthusiastic dancer. At 21, single and penniless, she gave her baby daughter up for adoption because she felt she couldn't provide for her. She kept it hidden from almost everyone, including her parents, but wove clues into her work for decades, including "Little Green" on Blue. She later said she was grateful for every bit of trouble, because bad fortune changed her destiny and made her a musician.
Al Kooper and Judy Collins
Enter Al Kooper, a session musician with a gift for being in the right place at the right time. He was the one who noticed an unoccupied organ during Bob Dylan's "Like a Rolling Stone" session and came up with its famous part. Later, in Joni's New York apartment, she played him "Both Sides Now". He rushed to the phone at 3am and called Judy Collins, an established folk star recording her sixth album, Wildflowers, and had Joni play it down the line.
Collins recorded it and won the 1969 Grammy for Best Folk Performance. Joni, still unsigned, didn't love that version, but she accepted Judy's invitation to perform at the Newport Folk Festival, where Judy introduced her to the world and to Leonard Cohen. Their romance was brief, but Joni said he showed her, without words, how to plumb the depths of her experience.
A restless career
Albums like Clouds, Court and Spark and Hejira made her a star, and she kept experimenting, working with jazz musicians who understood her unusual chords. Mingus (1979), made with Charles Mingus, was too much for some fans, and the 1980s were difficult years for her sound. She bounced back with the Grammy-winning Turbulent Indigo in 1994. Later, health problems made touring hard, and she used a guitar with a Roland modelling system so she could switch between her many tunings without retuning between songs. When fans complained they missed her acoustic, she famously told them, in effect, to deal with it. She has never cared what people think, and I love her for it.
For more on open tunings and fingerstyle, try my Fingerstyle Guitar course. For more breakdowns, read why "Fast Car" is perfect and writing songs about real people, which tells the story of Joni and Graham Nash.
