Here's a strange idea, but bear with me: what if MTV never existed? Picture a parallel universe where TV executives considered the proposal for music plus television and simply said no thanks. It isn't far-fetched. MTV wasn't inevitable, and many senior executives had no confidence in it. They were proved very wrong, and popular culture changed for ever.
A world without it
What would Dire Straits' "Money for Nothing" have been about, without its famous "I want my MTV" refrain? Would the Buggles have written a song celebrating the triumph of radio instead of "Video Killed the Radio Star"?
The so-called MTV generation was often described as lacking a central identity like the hippies or punks, supposedly defined only by cynicism and a love of music videos. Critics said MTV shortened attention spans, promoted recklessness, and made rock bland and corporate; the Dead Kennedys even wrote a song attacking it. So without it, would Generation X have been labelled focused and serious rather than slackers? Would hair metal have died early because the outfits were too embarrassing to wear in daylight? Would more bands have formed without endless entertainment on tap? Would the printed music press have kept thriving?
Music and video before MTV
MTV didn't invent the combination. In 1940s America, three-minute black-and-white "Soundies" played on the Panoram, a coin-operated film jukebox. The Big Bopper is said to have coined the term "music video" in 1959. In the 1960s, Scopitones, colour 16mm films shown on special visual jukeboxes, were popular in France and spread to Europe and the US, though they faded by the 1970s, partly because they targeted adults rather than teenagers. The Beatles focused on television appearances instead, and Queen's "Bohemian Rhapsody" video was a hit years before MTV launched.
But MTV's enormous, unexpected success meant labels poured money into ever bigger, more complex and more expensive videos. Without it, where would that money have gone? Perhaps into feature films, as with Elvis and the Beatles. Maybe we'd have had more long-form work from Madonna, Michael Jackson and Prince; imagine a two-hour Thriller to rival Purple Rain.
Making stars global
Talent at that level would still have broken through, but would it have gone truly global so quickly? A hit video could make an artist around the world almost overnight. Pat Benatar said her whole life changed within a week of MTV starting; suddenly everyone recognised her in the street. Many of the artists MTV made famous are still selling out stadiums today.
Without it, would the industry have been less image-focused? Would "a face for radio" mean something different? Might the album's golden era have lasted another decade or two, with a new batch of records to rival The Dark Side of the Moon?
How music video changed editing
One of MTV's biggest influences was on editing and storytelling. Music videos brought huge creative freedom: a release from strict narrative towards something visually stimulating, or a mix of both. Michael Mann, the producer behind Miami Vice, has described how Hollywood used to fit music to pictures, whereas MTV taught filmmakers to cut pictures to music, and showed them they didn't need so much clunky exposition. A whole generation of producers, directors and camera operators also got their start in the MTV gold rush, thrown in at the deep end.
For more music history, read about the history of the parental advisory label and the rise, fall and return of the CD.
