What a Million Views on YouTube Really Earned Me: RPM, CPM and Watch Time

Watch What a Million Views on YouTube Really Earned Me: RPM, CPM and Watch Time on YouTube

Watch the video on YouTube

I believe in transparency, so I want to share what I've learned as an independent musician who uses YouTube to market and monetise my music. Two years before this video, I explained how I earned almost nothing from a video with over a million views because of a copyright claim. You can read that story in the Content ID lesson that cost me. In an amusing twist, that video went on to get over 1.2 million views itself. So here's what it actually earned, and what that tells you about how YouTube pays. Figures are as I shared them at the time.

I'm not sharing this to show off. Many of my viewers are musicians and creators, and I want more people to take advantage of the platform. When one video succeeds, it lets me take a risk on the next, even if that one costs more to make than it will ever earn.

The numbers

That video had:

  • about 85,000 hours of watch time
  • around 8,500 new subscribers
  • estimated revenue of about $6,000 (just over £5,000)
  • 81% of viewers who weren't subscribed, and half of views from the United States

RPM vs CPM

  • RPM (revenue per mille) is what you earn per thousand views. On this video it was $5.13 (about £4.27). It includes all revenue sources: ads, channel memberships, YouTube Premium, Super Chat and Super Stickers. It's calculated by dividing your estimated revenue by your total views, including views on videos that weren't monetised.
  • CPM (cost per mille) is what advertisers pay per thousand ad impressions. Here it was $14.36 (about £11.94). It doesn't account for YouTube's share; typically the creator keeps about 55% of ad revenue and YouTube keeps 45%. CPM is really an advertiser's metric, which is why YouTube introduced RPM for creators.

Some videos aren't eligible for monetisation at all, for example if they use copyrighted material or adult content. Reaction videos to songs are often claimed straight away, because labels can then take all the revenue. This video was just me talking, all original, so it was fully monetised.

Why two similar videos earned different amounts

I compared it with why YouTube musicians can't play live, which had about 1.6 million views, over 60,000 hours of watch time, 11,000 new subscribers and about $4,392 (£3,652). Same audience geography, similar views, but less money. Why?

  • Watch time. There was a 20,000-hour difference. More engaged viewers mean more eyes on the screen when ads roll.
  • Length. One was 8 minutes 26 seconds, the other just over 12 minutes. Longer videos have more room for ads, and YouTube allows mid-roll ads on videos over eight minutes. Bear that in mind when you plan, but don't pad videos out; viewers can tell.
  • Topic. Advertisers bid for slots, and subjects like fitness, finance and technology command higher CPMs than music. Product reviews are also among the most watched types of video.

Why cover videos rarely pay

Covers usually mean sharing revenue with the copyright holder, typically the label. I had great success with a video where I finished John Mayer's new song from a snippet he'd posted on TikTok, before he released it. He shared my video and sent me the finished track to react to for a second video. Both did really well, but both were claimed by the label once the song came out, so the income stopped.

I wish YouTube could calculate how much of a video actually uses the music and divide revenue fairly. The tools are certainly sophisticated enough. Interacting with John that way was a dream come true, but it doesn't pay the bills. Original content, like my video essays, is what sustains my business. I break the economics down further in cover songs, copyright and money on YouTube.

Why I think musicians should learn creator skills

When I started out, I played four-hour cover sets in pubs, often to a handful of people, for £100 to £200. In the same four hours I can now write, record, edit and publish a video that could potentially earn 50 times that.

Of course, not every video gets a million views. At the time I'd had just over 10 videos pass a million, out of more than 500. A music video for one of my original songs had nearly 20,000 views and earned about £55, which went straight into the fund for my album. It took a few hours to shoot and edit. You don't need fancy cameras or complicated editing to start; you're building a catalogue, and sometimes you make things for yourself and your music.

It isn't a quick buck, and going viral isn't easy. I'm not suggesting you give up playing live, which is essential for becoming a better musician. But people are earning this way, and you could too.

My streaming income is very small by comparison, and it arrives more slowly than AdSense. And I think it's far easier to build a relationship with your audience on YouTube than on Spotify. People can see you, engage with you, and get notified about new videos when they subscribe. If you're a musician looking for your audience, think carefully about where you spend your time.

For more on the finances of being an independent musician, read what my original music has earned on YouTube and why I left Spotify.

Previous
Previous

CDs Are Back: Why Gen Z Is Buying Compact Discs Again

Next
Next

Writing Songs About Real People: Breakup Songs, Ethics and the Law