While watching one of my friend Rick Beato's live streams, a phrase leapt out at me: "boomer nostalgia". Boomers are the post-war generation, and nostalgia is a wistful, sentimental yearning for the past. I first explored this in why new music "sucks", and wanted to revisit the debate.
The boomer case
The argument goes that music was undeniably better back in the day. The greatest bands and solo artists, songs with real hooks, melodies and proper choruses, and a special connection to records that came from scarcity. The golden eras of rock, hip-hop, disco and metal. People really knew how to play, producers knew how to produce, and artists like Carole King, David Bowie, Marvin Gaye and James Taylor sold millions. Labels acted as gatekeepers, weeding out weaker music at the demo stage and giving artists time to develop. Tickets were cheaper. And today's music, so the argument goes, is auto-tuned, derivative nonsense made for TikTok dances.
The younger generations' response
Millennials and Gen Z reply: okay, boomer. Every generation rebels against what came before and criticises what comes after; these are the same arguments people made about the Beatles' tight trousers, the Rolling Stones' haircuts and punk's three chords. Music is more democratic now, with unparalleled access to the greatest libraries ever made, letting artists head in new, post-genre directions. The charts are the last gasp of a dying system that doesn't reflect what's truly popular. And wishing for the days when you could afford only a few records a year is like wishing we could go back to foraging for berries.
There's another point: when my generation listens to classic records, we can't hear them objectively. We hear them through decades of critical praise. Once something has been labelled a masterpiece, it's hard to form your own opinion. Many classic records weren't well reviewed at the time, and some work was only recognised decades later.
Both sides are right, and both are wrong
I try to be positive about 21st-century music, but if I'm honest, I have plenty of issues with the system:
- So much is released every day that I often move on before forming that special attachment to an album.
- Algorithms have served me real treats, but discovering independent artists still takes a lot of conscious searching, because streaming giants and major labels work hand in hand to push big releases.
- In the attention economy, a single notification about a superstar's new album can derail my whole afternoon.
- Playlist culture encourages artists to squeeze creativity into boxes like "gym" or "summer vibes" in the hope of being noticed.
I rarely look at the charts and think it must have been nice when artists like Prince or Tracy Chapman were what counted as popular. But some days I am wistful for good old days I never knew, especially when my practice and creative time is drained by the admin of making a living.
Would the legends have coped today?
I wonder whether the golden artists of the 1970s and 80s would have produced a fraction of their work if they'd had to tour relentlessly to make up for lost record income, while also being video editors, content creators and marketing gurus. Would Joni Mitchell have written such lyrics if she'd been on social media half the day? Would Don Henley have written "The Boys of Summer" between answering online-store enquiries and battling vinyl shortages? We'll never know.
Right or wrong, there's no going back. And like a true double-edged sword, the same technologies have let me build a direct connection with my audience, fund my debut album and plan to tour. For more, read streaming, mega-hits and why I focus on YouTube.
