Why New Music "Sucks": Nostalgia, Juvenoia and the Musical Smorgasbord

Watch Why New Music "Sucks": Nostalgia, Juvenoia and the Musical Smorgasbord on YouTube

Watch the video on YouTube

I want to start with four definitions:

  • Nostalgia: a wistful or excessively sentimental yearning for a past period.
  • Juvenoia: a term coined by the sociologist David Finkelhor for an older generation's fear of, or hostility towards, the young and youth culture.
  • Smorgasbord: originally a Swedish spread of various dishes; more broadly, an abundance or wide variety of something.
  • Generation Z: usually defined as people born from the mid-1990s to the early 2010s.

I was born in 1990, so I'm a millennial, just old enough to remember life before the internet: buying singles on cassette at HMV, saving up for an album on CD every month, obsessively reading NME and Kerrang! for recommendations. I remember the mystique of not even knowing what a band looked like beyond a press shot in a magazine. Things are radically different now.

Every generation says it

New music has always represented modernity. Ragtime, jazz and rock and roll each broke with the past, and each was almost universally hated by the parents of the kids who loved it. The beauty of music history is that each revolution doesn't wipe the slate clean. Grunge may have ended the hair metal era, but that music still exists, waiting to be rediscovered.

Older generations have always said things were better in their day. In Electric Shock, Peter Doggett quotes a 1926 newspaper story about a 79-year-old music professor who heard a jazz band, declared it wasn't music, and promptly collapsed. Yes, there's plenty of bad music in the charts. There always has been.

What we lost, and why I accept it

Older generations felt a special connection to records partly because they were scarce, and because there wasn't much else to do. Today there's a proliferation of entertainment, and yes, that affects attention spans. There's no going back. A single record is no longer the soundtrack to my life; my life has a constant soundtrack, and the access and variety I've had over the last decade is unparalleled.

We have lost some of the magic that rarity brought. There's unlikely to be another band like the Beatles capturing the world's zeitgeist in the same way, and modern genres like drum and bass or grime, however popular, didn't have rock and roll's seismic social effect, because there's so much more noise. That's a trade-off I'm willing to accept. Think of all the songs you heard once and never found again, or never heard at all, and the genres you never explored.

The age of the song

We're in a post-album world: the age of the song. The old industry's power lay in controlling physical distribution; you could only afford so many records a month, and few could afford to be a crate digger. My old way of listening was narrow. Now I have a smorgasbord: you don't have to pick one sandwich, you can try them all. Gen Z artists can mix their favourite genres and influences in new ways, and the system is more democratic than the old one, which was exploitative and handed power to a tiny few. Something new is still emerging, and there will be a course correction.

We're still hungry for music

The metrics have changed and sales alone don't reflect what's popular, but appetite for music is huge. Touring and licensing have grown, and video game soundtracks have become works of art in their own right, from Halo and The Last of Us to Final Fantasy, Red Dead Redemption, the Grand Theft Auto series and Tony Hawk's Pro Skater. A 2022 Guardian article reported that around a quarter to a third of people discover new music through games, more among Gen Z, and EA's head of music described a song in FIFA being heard around the world nearly a billion times. No medium in recorded-music history has offered such instant global exposure.

For my later take on where things are heading, read streaming, mega-hits and why I focus on YouTube, and for the history, what if MTV never existed?

Previous
Previous

My Problem with Boomer Nostalgia: Was Music Really Better Back Then?

Next
Next

Streaming, Mega-Hits and Why I Think YouTube Is the Best Bet for Musicians