Streaming, Mega-Hits and Why I Think YouTube Is the Best Bet for Musicians

Watch Streaming, Mega-Hits and Why I Think YouTube Is the Best Bet for Musicians on YouTube

Watch the video on YouTube

Two years after my video "Why New Music Sucks", I wanted to revisit my hopes and fears for musicians and the music industry. I try not to make too many negative industry videos, because nobody likes a moaner, and I still believe there are plenty of reasons to be optimistic. Figures here are as I shared them in mid-2025.

Part one: streaming is working for Spotify

Spotify announced its best-ever results in 2024, its first full year of profit, around $1.5 billion. It also celebrated ten years of generating billions for the music industry. Its annual report talks about a mission to get the world to value music again, and says the system is working. It certainly seems to be working for Spotify. Over the previous few years, its founders and senior management sold shares worth over $1 billion in total, money that leaves the music ecosystem for good. Spotify's market value had grown to more than double Universal Music Group's.

It's not really the music industry any more; it's the tech industry. And the more it moves away from the magic of music towards analytics, algorithms and AI content, the less attractive it becomes to people who truly value music.

I do still put my music on Spotify, with a delay. Does that make me a hypocrite? Perhaps. There's no perfect alternative yet. But you shouldn't stay in a toxic relationship just because you're scared of being alone. (I later left Spotify as a listener.)

Part two: the peak of the pop mountain

Streaming has profoundly changed how we listen. In May 2025, Bruno Mars was the most popular artist on Spotify, with over 130 million monthly listeners. No shade to him: he's immensely talented. But the numbers are staggering. "Die with a Smile" hit a billion plays in 96 days, and "APT." with Rosé passed 1.5 billion streams in about eight months.

Things are speeding up. Drake's "One Dance" was the first song to reach a billion plays on Spotify, taking 193 days in 2016. According to data from How Music Charts, songs released in 2015 took an average of 2,621 days to hit a billion streams, songs from 2020 about 1,250 days, and by 2024 just 180 days. The number of songs joining the billion club keeps rising sharply each year.

A billion streams doesn't mean a billion different listeners; it's a share of people playing the same songs over and over. The top 1% of tracks receive the vast majority of streams, because listeners overwhelmed by choice lean on curated playlists, and social media trends follow the herd too. The inevitable result is that niche and strange music gets squeezed out in favour of mega-hits.

Even if the biggest stars all quit or united to negotiate better terms, I don't think much would change. Prices will rise, tiers will multiply, artist payments will be minimised, and the platform will keep chasing growth, while filling up with AI-generated music, audiobooks, podcasts and video.

Part three: why I focus on YouTube

I've been trying to make it as a singer-songwriter since I was 15, and like many musicians I've tried to cover every base: MySpace, Bebo, Facebook, Twitter, YouTube, Spotify, Instagram, TikTok, newsletters, Discord. It's overwhelming, and you end up a jack of all trades. I realised the best thing I can do is focus on the one thing I do best, and do it well. For me that's YouTube. This is my personal experience, and it's as much advice to myself as anyone.

  • It's huge and stable, with billions of monthly users, unlike platforms that could disappear.
  • It does everything in one place: short and long videos, live streams, music, comments and posts, AdSense, tipping and paid memberships.
  • It's easier to publish often on YouTube than to keep releasing on Spotify.
  • Diversify your content. Per view, AdSense isn't so different from a stream, roughly a third of a cent, but it varies by topic, so a varied mix builds a more sustainable business.
  • It's deeply human. You can take people with you as you build and learn, and there's real hunger for authentic content without complex editing or clickbait thumbnails. New and smaller channels are recommended more than they used to be.

It has challenges too: AI-generated content, music being used to train AI without permission or compensation, and the difficulty of being noticed. Uploading week after week is hard when it feels like nobody's watching. I've made plenty of mistakes, and I'm still learning, but I'm glad this is where I focused my energy. Choose your own adventure: upload a song or a cover, or simply share what you're working on.

Read more in what a million YouTube views earned me, or support my work directly through my store.

Previous
Previous

Why New Music "Sucks": Nostalgia, Juvenoia and the Musical Smorgasbord

Next
Next

Why Are Vinyl Records So Expensive? An Independent Artist's View