At the end of 2021, the big news was that Bruce Springsteen had sold his music catalogue to Sony for a reported $500 million, a record-setting deal. He followed other artists who had sold publishing rights, including Stevie Nicks, Neil Young, Paul Simon and Bob Dylan, whose deal was reported at around $300 million. I asked my followers what they thought, and in this video I share their reactions and my own.
Why publishing matters
Publishing is a prized possession. One thing I've learned, not that I've had any offers, and definitely nothing close to $500 million, is to keep 100% of it, and never sell until someone turns up with an offer that makes it worthwhile. For a primer on how rights and royalties work, see cover songs, YouTube and copyright.
In his statement, Springsteen said that when he signed with Columbia in 1972 he came to the right place, that the people at Sony had treated him with great respect for 50 years, and that he was thrilled his legacy would be cared for by people he knew and trusted. After half a century with the same company, selling to them at that price makes sense. It may also simplify things for his family and estate in the future.
What my followers said
The responses ranged widely. Many said it was a smart move, that he'd earned it and could do what he liked. Some pointed out that he'd won twice: he came up in an era when artists actually earned money from record sales, and now he's cashing in again. Others joked that he'd need a very good accountant, or that we'd be hearing a lot more Springsteen as Sony tried to recoup its investment. A few called him a sellout, or suggested he no longer cared about his music.
The trouble with "sellout"
I find the word "sellout" really tricky, and I don't like using it. If someone does something morally wrong, like promoting something harmful for money, perhaps it applies. But an artist selling their own music, which has been their business for 50 years, is not selling out. We don't know how much of the money actually reaches him, or what he'll do with it, so we shouldn't be too quick to judge. I wonder if the word sometimes comes from insecurity. Some people might see a musician like me making YouTube videos as selling out, and I don't think that's true either.
Nor do I believe he doesn't care about his music. When nobody was listening to me, knowing that Springsteen played marathon concerts while I was doing four-hour cover sets in pubs genuinely spurred me on. Very different audiences, very different repertoire, but it kept me going. As John Mayer put it in an Instagram post, it's a bit like selling a start-up you built.
The scale of the catalogue business
I was struck to learn that Sony Music Publishing reportedly controls rights to a substantial share of songs streamed on Spotify, at a time when anyone can upload music through a distributor. Deals like this add to that collection. Publishing is a strange business, and I think it's changing, but this deal also shows that Columbia's long-term support helped make those records possible. I write more about the label side in major labels vs going independent.
Have an extraordinary goal
One response joked that he could lend them a few bucks. I'd turn that around: what can we each do, over the years we have ahead, to one day be in a position like this? Have small, achievable goals along the way, but also an extraordinary goal so far out of reach that achieving it isn't really the point. It's about enjoying the process rather than waiting to feel you've "made it", because life doesn't work like that.
For me, that goal is selling out Wembley Stadium. It's so unattainable right now that it keeps me going. Even if I do it at 72, I'll have enjoyed every step. In the meantime, I'll keep writing, recording and uploading. And if anyone says Springsteen only has a handful of good songs, go and listen to his records properly. For ideas on building your own income, read how to start making money as a musician.
