According to reports, the compact disc is back in fashion, and the surge is being driven by Gen Z. People aged roughly 13 to 38 are seeking a connection to music in a world that traded ownership for access, and found that it can feel a bit hollow. My two previous videos on why physical music still matters were met with a flood of comments championing the CD, so it was time to pay tribute to it.
The invention
The technology was invented by James T. Russell, a physicist from Washington state who was frustrated by the damage needles did to his LPs. He imagined a format that didn't need physical contact, and decided light was the best way to read the data. In 1965 he developed a method of optical digital recording and playback, encoding sound as microscopic patterns of light and dark that a laser could scan and a computer could turn back into sound.
In 1979, engineers at Sony and Philips began developing an audio disc to replace the cassette. They disagreed over size: Philips wanted something close to a cassette, while Sony wanted a larger disc with more playing time. Legend has it that Beethoven settled it, because a Sony executive's wife wanted the Ninth Symphony to fit on one disc. The longest known performance lasted about 74 minutes, requiring the 120mm diameter we know today.
It's a nice story, but a Philips engineer has suggested the real reason was competitive: Philips had already built a plant in Germany for a smaller disc, and Sony couldn't let Philips have that head start. I explain how the discs themselves are manufactured in how CDs are made.
The boom and the bust
CDs launched in 1982 and outsold LPs within five years and cassettes within ten. Players that cost over $2,000 fell to under $350 within two years. US pressing plants went from two to more than 50, and as production costs fell, labels rushed to reissue their entire back catalogues on CD, often at a higher price than the equivalent LP. Shops couldn't stock everything, and the bargain bin became a familiar sight.
Then the MP3 changed everything. Global CD sales peaked around 2000, with over two billion discs sold and about $25 billion in revenue. MP3s, file sharing and streaming took a huge toll, and by 2014 revenue had fallen by around 90%, the music industry's lowest point. But the CD never died: in 2024, CDs still accounted for about half a billion dollars of sales in the US.
Why some listeners prefer CDs
Audiophiles will tell you CDs are hard to beat for sound quality. Most streaming is heavily compressed, and even lossless files are limited by Bluetooth headphones, which can only handle so much data. In my cassette video, many of you pointed out how few quality tape mechanisms are still made. CD players, by contrast, have kept improving, because a dedicated fan base never stopped buying them and brands kept investing.
Japan: the country that protects the CD
Japan, the world's second-biggest music market after the US, is still very much in love with the CD. In 2023, 39% of its recorded music revenue came from CDs. That's partly thanks to a government-mandated resale price maintenance system, saihan seido, which lets owners of certain copyrighted works, including books, records and CDs, set a minimum retail price. That prevents the race-to-the-bottom discounting we see in the West, gave the industry a lot of power, and for a long time kept many artists off streaming services. Japanese artists, often called idols, are also heavily promoted through record-shop meet-and-greets, where buying a CD is your ticket in.
Superfans, vinyl prices and second-hand shops
Superfans are one factor in the revival. They want to support their favourite artists and display their complete collections, even if that means buying multiple versions of the same album.
The vinyl renaissance has also become the industry's golden goose, and a new LP can cost over £40, or £50 for a double. A CD is much more affordable, and you might even be able to play it in your car. In the UK, Coldplay's Moon Music was the best-selling CD of 2024 with about 204,000 copies, just ahead of Taylor Swift's The Tortured Poets Department at about 197,000.
But giants like Taylor Swift and Coldplay skew the data. The real revival, which is much harder to measure, is in bargain bins, charity shops and eBay. For the youngest members of Gen Z, a second-hand CD from the 1980s, picked up for a few pounds, feels like a precious artefact.
Why owning music matters
Actually owning something is where the joy is, and we're seeing it with records, cassettes, books and clothes. Online shopping is practical but joyless, and endless digital choice is overwhelming, unemotional and fragile. Songs disappear from streaming all the time; Neil Young removed his whole catalogue from Spotify for a few years. When you own the disc, nobody can take it away.
If you'd like to own my music, my CDs and other physical releases are in my store. You can also read why I chose to take my music off Spotify.
