The Dark Side of Ambition: Mental Health, Touring and the Music Industry

Watch The Dark Side of Ambition: Mental Health, Touring and the Music Industry on YouTube

Watch the video on YouTube

This is a follow-up to an earlier video I made about the brutal realities of the corporate music industry: endless touring, the pressure of the spotlight, and the psychological toll when that time comes to an end. That video struck a nerve, and it became clear that this is something people want, and need, to talk about. Just as I sat down to record this one, Lewis Capaldi announced he was stepping back from touring to focus on his mental and physical health, which only underlined how current this is.

A conversation with Ian Winwood

One of my favourite books of the previous year was Bodies: Life and Death in Music by Ian Winwood, a long-time Kerrang! journalist and author of books on Metallica and Green Day. It explores the industry's reluctance to confront its failures, and I caught up with Ian to discuss whether things are getting better or worse.

His point stayed with me. By the time an artist is famous enough for the public to know their name, they've already endured hardships most people can't imagine: years honing their craft, playing to nobody, sleeping on floors, freezing in vans, getting ripped off and rejected. The ones who remain are the tough ones. So when they say they're exhausted and need to step away, believe them. They're not weak; they just need a break.

Ian also described the frantic tempo of the industry: you've arrived, you're happening, so work, work, work, with the unspoken implication that your time is limited and someone else will fill your spot. He believes that if audiences and artists value each other, that drumbeat can be slowed down.

It isn't just the stars

This affects everyone on tour: sound engineers, lighting technicians and road crew face the same gruelling grind. A peer-reviewed study published in the Journal of Psychiatric Research in 2021, based on a pre-pandemic survey of more than 1,100 international touring professionals, found elevated risks of serious mental health problems, including depression, anxiety, stress and burnout. Nineteen-hour days, months-long tours, temporary contracts, difficulty keeping up healthy routines and relationships, and financial insecurity all contributed. A 2023 UK industry survey of crew found that around four in ten had experienced mental health issues during a tour, even more had afterwards, and the large majority had never received mental health first aid training.

The pandemic made things worse. Two years with little or no work drained savings, and many people left for more stable jobs. Those who returned found schedules busier than ever as promoters tried to recoup lost income. Say yes, and you're a disposable cog in a huge machine; say no, and you fear being forgotten and unable to pay your bills. Grassroots venues, essential to a healthy industry, are under huge strain too, as I explain in why grassroots venues need our help.

People already helping

Music itself isn't the problem; it can be powerful therapy and one of our greatest joys. But in the absence of change from above, several organisations are stepping in:

  • 320 Changes Direction, founded by Talinda Bennington, widow of Linkin Park's Chester Bennington, raises mental health awareness and connects people with resources.
  • Backline connects musicians, crew and their families with a clinical network of therapists, psychiatrists, psychologists and coaches, many offering reduced-rate or pro bono support.
  • The Music Industry Therapist Collective was set up by psychotherapist Tamsin Embleton, author of Touring and Mental Health: The Music Industry Manual. She has spoken about clients still rebuilding their lives years after being dropped by a label, when the phone suddenly stops ringing and a whole sense of self can shatter.

What could change

I don't pretend to have all the answers, and none of this will happen overnight. But here's where I'd start:

  • Redefine success. A career in music doesn't have to mean private jets between stadiums. A long career without burning out is possible.
  • Basic protections. I'm lucky to have the NHS, but that isn't the case everywhere. Some well-known US musicians, including Wilco's Jeff Tweedy, have said they struggled to get life insurance because musicians are seen as a risk.
  • Industry giants should contribute. Live Nation set up Crew Nation during the pandemic with a $10 million pledge, which is welcome, but set against its billions in annual gross profit, the companies profiting from crews and creatives could do far more. The same goes for streaming services.
  • Government support for recording, touring and grassroots venues would be a drop in the ocean of national budgets, with profound long-term effects.
  • Better conditions for crew: training, more flexible working and safety nets like sick pay.
  • A duty of care from labels to prepare artists for life on the road, rather than working them until they drop.
  • Audiences can stop glamorising bad behaviour, and be kinder to artists who say they need a break.

Why I talk about this

Most of all, we shouldn't stop talking about it, and we can all help remove the stigma around therapy. I'm in therapy myself, because I recognise that I have a far from normal life, and like so many people I deal with anxiety and negative thoughts. I'm lucky that I don't have to tour relentlessly, but the effects of social media and life as an online creator are well known, and I want to do everything I can to look after myself, because I want to be doing this for a long while yet. Physical health matters too; I write about protecting your ears in tinnitus and hearing protection for musicians.

If you're struggling, please reach out to someone you trust or one of the organisations above. Look after yourself.

Previous
Previous

Why I Gave Up on the Record Label Dream: Major Labels vs Going Independent

Next
Next

Streaming vs Physical Sales: Why I Held My Album Back from Spotify