For as long as there's been music, there have been people looking to profit from other people's work. I don't mean borrowing a chord progression or drawing inspiration from a song. I mean bootleggers. Music piracy goes back much further than file sharing.
The first pirates
We can't know for sure, but the first music pirates were probably the scribes, monks and priests who copied sacred music by hand. It was painstaking work, and it's likely the occasional extra copy was made for a little extra income. This was long before copyright; apart from royal patronage, composing often wasn't rewarded financially at all. Music was its own reward. No change there.
From the 15th century, composers could make a small living selling handwritten and printed scores. With a piano at home often the only way to hear a piece, pirated scores were big business. In 19th-century Britain, tens of thousands of sheets of pirated music were seized, and the black market forced publishers to cut their prices dramatically. Some composers took control: Georg Philipp Telemann, the original DIY musician, self-published his scores and even ran a subscription service for his fans. Mozart complained that unauthorised copying hurt his income.
Mozart, the original file sharer
But Mozart wasn't squeaky clean. Gregorio Allegri's Miserere, a setting of Psalm 51 from the 1630s, was performed in the Sistine Chapel during Holy Week, and its score was a closely guarded secret, with excommunication threatened for anyone who copied it. At 14, Mozart heard it, went home, and transcribed it almost perfectly from memory, returning a few days later to make corrections. It was published soon after (though historians debate whether his was the copy used). Rather than being excommunicated, he was made a knight of the Order of the Golden Spur. Like many pirates since, he got away with it.
Printing and the first copyright laws
Gutenberg's press made mass production of information possible, but Ottaviano Petrucci is known as the father of music printing: the first to print polyphonic music, using a triple-impression technique that printed staff lines, notes and text separately for much clearer results. Publishers like Artaria in Vienna and Breitkopf & Härtel in Leipzig went on to publish the great composers of their day.
Britain's Statute of Anne, passed in 1710, was the first modern copyright law, recognising authors rather than printers as owners of their work for a set term, after which it entered the public domain. At first it covered books and printed works. In the United States, the Copyright Act of 1790 began a long process of protecting creators. In the 19th century, publishers took legal action against counterfeiters, but recorded music was about to complicate everything. A 1908 US Supreme Court case ruled that makers of player-piano rolls didn't have to pay composers, because the rolls weren't readable copies of the notation, a gap later laws had to fix.
Bootleg vinyl
The first well-known bootleg LP was Great White Wonder, a collection of unreleased Bob Dylan material that appeared while fans were hungry for his earlier sound. Beatles and Rolling Stones bootlegs followed. When Rolling Stone covered them in 1970, demand only grew. Artists decided that if they couldn't beat the pirates, they'd join them: the Stones released Get Yer Ya-Ya's Out!, and The Who's Live at Leeds was even packaged to look like a bootleg.
Pirates also copied hit records onto tape, pressed their own runs with recreated artwork, and sold them at markets or by mail order. It continues today: the vinyl revival has led to sophisticated bootleg operations, and a 2024 police raid in Britain seized thousands of counterfeit records and several pressing machines.
How music got onto the internet
Someone had to upload it, but where did the files come from? A good deal of early online music was traced back to one man. In the 1990s, Dell Glover was a temporary worker at a PolyGram CD plant in North Carolina, which could produce a quarter of a million discs a day. New albums were pressed weeks before release, and leaks from the factory floor were common, though they usually went no further than the boot of someone's car.
Glover was an early internet user, active in chat rooms where people traded files for status rather than money. When the MP3, developed by a team of German engineers led by Karlheinz Brandenburg, shrank audio files dramatically, he realised he couldn't hear the difference from a CD. He went on to smuggle discs out of the plant, famously hidden behind a belt buckle, and they were ripped and uploaded before release. It was an old-fashioned inside job that helped transform the music industry.
For more on how formats shaped music, read why CDs are back and how CDs are made.
