When I released my debut studio album, Super. Sexy. Heartbreak., on CD, many of you told me you'd love to buy it but no longer own a CD player, though you do have a turntable. So I wanted to explain what it's like to release vinyl as an independent artist, and why records cost what they do.
A very short history of recorded sound
- The phonautograph: in Paris in the 1850s, Édouard-Léon Scott de Martinville captured sound waves with a stylus. In 1860 he recorded a fragment of the French folk song "Au clair de la lune", but no playback equipment existed, so he couldn't prove what he'd achieved.
- The phonograph: Thomas Edison made sound playable in 1877, using tin foil wrapped around a grooved cylinder.
- The graphophone: about a decade later, Alexander Graham Bell and his collaborators used wax and engraving.
- The gramophone: in the 1890s, German-born inventor Emile Berliner patented the flat disc, tracing a line through wax on a zinc disc and etching it in acid to create a playable groove.
By 1912 flat discs had beaten Edison's cylinders, which ended in 1929. Records were often made from shellac until polyvinyl chloride, vinyl, took over in the late 1940s, and the 45rpm single and 33rpm LP made the format dominant until CDs and MP3s arrived.
Collapse and revival
Vinyl sales crashed in the late 1980s when distributors changed returns policies. Shops ordered more cautiously, labels released fewer albums on vinyl, pressing plants closed, and thousands of record shops followed as people switched to CDs and digital.
Then, in 2008, new LP sales in the US rose dramatically for the first time in decades. The reasons were probably a mix: Record Store Day began in 2007; films and TV like High Fidelity, 500 Days of Summer and The O.C. showed characters with record collections; electronic music boomed; and cheap turntables and coloured vinyl appeared in high-street chains. Sales have grown year after year since.
Superstars have driven huge demand. Taylor Swift sold over 100,000 vinyl copies of Evermore in a week in 2021, and in 2022 roughly one in every 25 vinyl LPs sold in the US was one of hers. Adele, Harry Styles, Coldplay and even ABBA have all released new albums on vinyl.
The bottleneck
That has created more demand than supply:
- Many surviving pressing plants use old equipment, and expanding capacity takes time and money.
- A fire at Apollo Masters, one of very few places in the world making the lacquer discs used in vinyl production, made things worse.
- The pandemic and the war in Ukraine increased shipping and raw-material costs.
- Major-label releases and Record Store Day exclusives took up plant capacity, causing delays of nine to twelve months for independent records at the peak, though I'm told it's since come down to two or three months.
As a result, a new record can easily cost around $45, even with mass production.
What it means for independent artists
For smaller labels, independent artists and DJs, long lead times mean hoping demand is still there when the stock finally arrives, and for some, selling merch at shows is their main income. Vinyl is also expensive to make in ways listeners don't always see: as well as the records, you need remastering for vinyl and resized artwork. It's fragile and costly to ship, and every copy broken or lost in the post brings an independent artist closer to a loss.
That's why CDs have been my first choice of physical product so far. A subscriber count doesn't automatically translate into album sales, so for an emerging artist, pre-orders are a brilliant way to find out whether the demand is there before committing to a pressing.
For more on physical music, read vinyl and the magic of scarcity and why CDs are back. You can find my releases in my store.
