Six Months Without Spotify: What Changed and What I Learned

Watch Six Months Without Spotify: What Changed and What I Learned on YouTube

Watch the video on YouTube

Six months before this video, I left Spotify, and far more of you watched that video than I expected. Afterwards I received hundreds of thoughtful emails and comments from people who'd been asking the same questions, often for years. This is my update after actually living without it. (This video was sponsored by Qobuz; more on how that came about below.)

I'll be honest: part of me wants to make a tiny dent in Spotify's armour. Not because one person leaving changes the world, but because I think we massively underestimate the power of where we spend our money, as listeners, as artists and as people who care about music.

Two relationships with Spotify

Leaving felt surprisingly nerve-racking, because I'd used Spotify in two ways for more than a decade.

As a listener, I'd had it since university, from the ad-supported free version to Premium. That means I'd spent a lot of money renting access to music I don't own, and I'd started to feel guilty about how little of it reaches the musicians I love.

As an artist, I'd uploaded my music through several distributors over the years and now use DistroKid. People streamed my songs and I got paid, never as much as you'd hope, but enough to feel part of the system.

Less than 1%

When I looked at the numbers properly, streaming accounted for less than 1% of my income from original music. I've probably spent more on Spotify subscriptions over the years than Spotify has ever paid me as an artist. That's a calculation worth making for yourself.

You could say that's because I'm a niche independent artist. Maybe. But I know musicians with millions of streams asking the same question: what is this system optimising for? If it isn't sustaining artists, who is it working for?

Questioning the default route

Musicians have been handed a very specific definition of success: upload constantly, release constantly, feed the algorithm, chase playlists, build momentum through quantity. I'm increasingly unconvinced that advice works, or ever did. Maybe Spotify becomes a place for discovery, one piece of a bigger ecosystem, and artists think more intentionally about how they release work. I don't have all the answers, but we should be brave enough to question the route we've all quietly accepted.

To be clear, this isn't a "delete Spotify" message. I'm not removing my existing music, I'm not demanding a boycott, and Spotify has helped people discover me. But there are alternatives, and with surprisingly little effort we can redistribute where our money goes. For most of us, money is one of the few votes we really have.

Where I listen now

I first moved to YouTube Music, because I already paid for YouTube Premium. But I found the experience frustrating. It still didn't feel cohesive, and I couldn't listen to a full album without the algorithm changing lanes and playing something I hadn't asked for.

I then switched to Qobuz, which music journalists had been recommending as a more ethical alternative, and I'm a paying customer. The sponsorship came after I'd already left Spotify, made the original video and discovered Qobuz on my own; they didn't create the questions, they just offered one possible answer. The audio quality is far better, but that isn't the only thing that kept me there.

If you want to support my music directly, the best way is to buy from my store. For more on where artists' money really comes from, read what a million YouTube views earned me and why CDs are back.

Previous
Previous

Why "Take It to the Limit" by the Eagles Is Perfect

Next
Next

The Lava Studio: A Smart Guitar Amp That Surprised Me